• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Hook choice???

Huanzhou Zhu said:
I really like the curve shank hook from bank tackle, bought barbed one in different sizes, but I found sometimes it is difficult to unhook the fish, will give barbless a go.
Click to expand...
Yeah I buy micro barbed then squeeze the barb down to leave a bump.
The only time I leave barbs in place is on 1 side of a treble hook. (1 barbed 2 barbless)
This is to simply stop me throwing the dead bait from the hooks and rarely does it end up in the pike.
 
I'm not a fan on the Bank Tackle hooks - two have straightened on me; one with a fish, the other pulling from a snag. Size 10 both times.
Granted I was using braid mainline with the fish, however I'd like to have confidence when putting pressure on.
The snag - was using 12lb mono and I pulled for a break from a snag on the far bank of the trent. The hook came back straight, which is disappointing.
Moved on to Korum S5s and Korun wide gape, in size 8.
 
Been using Teflon rapier for years..
www.ebay.co.uk

Teflon Rapier Series Carp Fishing Hooks - Click Here! | eBay

<p> </p> <ul> <li>Various sizes available - select your size at the top of the screen!</li> <li>Buy in bulk to save money - select you pack size at the top of the screen!</li> <li>Micro barbed. Straight eye.</li> <li>Chemically sharpened</li> <li>Teflon Coated. Matt black</li> </ul>...
www.ebay.co.uk
 
Richard Parsons said:
I'm not a fan on the Bank Tackle hooks - two have straightened on me; one with a fish, the other pulling from a snag. Size 10 both times.
Granted I was using braid mainline with the fish, however I'd like to have confidence when putting pressure on.
The snag - was using 12lb mono and I pulled for a break from a snag on the far bank of the trent. The hook came back straight, which is disappointing.
Moved on to Korum S5s and Korun wide gape, in size 8.
Click to expand...
I never had an issue with bank tackle hooks, but I had few straightened with drennan hooks in the past.
 
I’ve had a couple straighten out (size 10) when pulling for a break , but that’s expected , plus I only lose the hook and not the feeder / bomb etc
 
Terry Simner said:
Yep, not used a barbed hook for barbel for many (~15) years ....not since I learned how to keep a tight line to a hooked fish😁
Click to expand...
I started using micro barbed last year after never using barbed before due to losing 1 in 3 fish to hook pulls most of which were when I’d got the fish to within a rod length out. I’d started using new rods at the start of the season and that’s the only thing I could put it down to. My old rod was a lot softer so could handle the lunges under the rod tip. After losing what felt like moby dick on the lower Severn I switched to micro barbed and have only lost a couple since always within a few seconds of being hooked
 
Richard Parsons said:
For me, that's less than satisfactory. What if that was a big barbel? That's the point (excuse the pun) really.
Click to expand...
There’s way more force pulling for a break ( caught on a snag) than I’d ever put on a barbel , I mean I’m literally walking back with rod in hand ( rod is pointing straight to the snag ) and line singing in the breeze
Plus the barbel don’t grow that big in Yorkshire 😉
 
Kevin Brown said:
There’s way more force pulling for a break ( caught on a snag) than I’d ever put on a barbel , I mean I’m literally walking back with rod in hand ( rod is pointing straight to the snag ) and line singing in the breeze
Plus the barbel don’t grow that big in Yorkshire 😉
Click to expand...
Yeah - I get that (size wise), but the hook shouldn't be the weak point in an angler's rig, in my opinion. Pulling out of a snag aside, it certainly shouldn't straighten in a fish's mouth.

So, for me, Bank Tackle hooks are no longer part of my terminal tackle.
 
Richard Parsons said:
Yeah - I get that (size wise), but the hook shouldn't be the weak point in an angler's rig, in my opinion. Pulling out of a snag aside, it certainly shouldn't straighten in a fish's mouth.

So, for me, Bank Tackle hooks are no longer part of my terminal tackle.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I agree, if the hook straighten in a fish’s mouth, bin it.
 
I've been a Gardner user for many years.

Their Talon Tip wide gapes are exceptional hooks. The size 10's are a great size for a lot of different hookbaits from maggots to 15mm boilies. Anything bigger I'll use a size 8 and big meat a size 2.

The thick wire gauge doesn't impede sharpness or performance despite making them a heavy hook.

The Gardner Speci Hooks in 12/14/16 are the same hook just marketed differently for the likes of us and tench anglers.

Don't mistake them for the new Speci Beak Point hooks though, these have only been around a couple of years and are poor in comparison. Thin wire gauge, strange shaped eye, not particularly sharp and poorly engineered where the eye is closed against the shank.

Thanks

Lewis
 
Kevin Brown said:
There’s way more force pulling for a break ( caught on a snag) than I’d ever put on a barbel , I mean I’m literally walking back with rod in hand ( rod is pointing straight to the snag ) and line singing in the breeze
Plus the barbel don’t grow that big in Yorkshire 😉
Click to expand...

NO NO NO !!!!!!!! NEVER EVER DO THAT. You could end up with a lead or feeder flying at you with terrific speed. Keep the tip of the rod as low as possible, preferbly under the water.
 
Derek Funcks said:
NO NO NO !!!!!!!! NEVER EVER DO THAT. You could end up with a lead or feeder flying at you with terrific speed. Keep the tip of the rod as low as possible, preferbly under the water.
Click to expand...
Thanks for your concern 😊
 
Derek Funcks said:
NO NO NO !!!!!!!! NEVER EVER DO THAT. You could end up with a lead or feeder flying at you with terrific speed. Keep the tip of the rod as low as possible, preferbly under the water.
Click to expand...
100% correct this is what can happen...................................... he was very lucky it could have been his EYE !!!!!
 

Attachments

  • lead mouth.jpg
    lead mouth.jpg
    34.3 KB · Views: 179
Lewis Baldwin said:
I've been a Gardner user for many years.

Their Talon Tip wide gapes are exceptional hooks. The size 10's are a great size for a lot of different hookbaits from maggots to 15mm boilies. Anything bigger I'll use a size 8 and big meat a size 2.

The thick wire gauge doesn't impede sharpness or performance despite making them a heavy hook.

The Gardner Speci Hooks in 12/14/16 are the same hook just marketed differently for the likes of us and tench anglers.

Don't mistake them for the new Speci Beak Point hooks though, these have only been around a couple of years and are poor in comparison. Thin wire gauge, strange shaped eye, not particularly sharp and poorly engineered where the eye is closed against the shank.

Thanks

Lewis
Click to expand...
Talon tips are great hooks. Last time I was looking in several shops. Could only see mugga Carp hooks.
 
Bill Walford said:
In one of the rain breaks in the cricket this morning I dropped Bank Tackle an email suggesting that there might be a market for at least a size 12 in the range. I’ll let you know their response Joe…..on the subject of cricket! I wish I’d stayed in bed ☹️
Click to expand...
Some good news for Bank Tackle hook users. Had a reply back from Peter Chick at BT this morning and they do intend adding smaller sizes to the range. The bad news is that no date a the moment 😩
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top