• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Upstream or downstream if fishing in a group?

John Parker

Senior Member
For interest - If you were to fish in a group, say of three people would your preference be to be upstream, downstream or in the middle?
I've got my own opinion, but I'm interested to hear what people have experienced :)
 
Upstream for me!

A mate and I have doubled up in a swim quite a few times this year and out of the 7 bites we've had between us; 6 have come to the upstream rod. Not conclusive in anyway but backs up my theory that upstreaming is the best presentation on a river.

ATB
 
Upstream for me!

A mate and I have doubled up in a swim quite a few times this year and out of the 7 bites we've had between us; 6 have come to the upstream rod. Not conclusive in anyway but backs up my theory that upstreaming is the best presentation on a river.

ATB
Ash do you find also like me that the bigger fish tend to come from the upstream rod? Mate
 
Are we talking all 3 on the same peg or on 3 pegs next to each other? Either way I’d probably rather be downstream unless i knew the pegs and knew which one was best lol. If all on same peg the middle would probably be my last choice
 
Not in the middle ! Upstream swim you have first chance of intercepting /catching Barbel that are moving downstream , vice versa on the downstream swim . In match fishing drawing a downstream end peg is often seen as good as any fish moving upstream into the length meet your bait first , presuming of course that there isn't anyone further downstream who has already got their attention . I think disturbance can also be a factor , three anglers all fishing closely together create a fair bit of disturbance , that may spook the Barbel , in effect you have 3 anglers fishing for the same fish , presuming of course that there are any fish there in the first place . All this said fish don't always do what you expect . I was chatting to a couple of Barbel anglers the other day who were sharing a swim , obviously good pals and good anglers , they were fishing within 5 yards of each other and were hooking fish after fish , they were enjoying tremendous sport and having a good old natter as well , great to see . I am no match angler but on occasion I fish short duration summer club matches usually no more than 15 anglers , at the weigh in if the river is low usually only 2 or 3 anglers will have caught a Barbel , most are on the tip using baits that will catch Barbel , usually its the Bream that make up the winning weight , stick 3 anglers on the same stretch in similar conditions and more Barbel will be caught , I think the greater number of anglers , causes more disturbance and less Barbel are caught as a result . Anyway it matters not , you can't beat a good natter when your fishing , after all its not all about catching fish is it !
 
I like to be end peg, downstream but time and again I’ve had better results upstream, that said I use whacky flavoured baits that may have some pulling power over run of the mill pellets and boilies.
 
Not in the middle ! Upstream swim you have first chance of intercepting /catching Barbel that are moving downstream , vice versa on the downstream swim . In match fishing drawing a downstream end peg is often seen as good as any fish moving upstream into the length meet your bait first , presuming of course that there isn't anyone further downstream who has already got their attention . I think disturbance can also be a factor , three anglers all fishing closely together create a fair bit of disturbance , that may spook the Barbel , in effect you have 3 anglers fishing for the same fish , presuming of course that there are any fish there in the first place . All this said fish don't always do what you expect . I was chatting to a couple of Barbel anglers the other day who were sharing a swim , obviously good pals and good anglers , they were fishing within 5 yards of each other and were hooking fish after fish , they were enjoying tremendous sport and having a good old natter as well , great to see . I am no match angler but on occasion I fish short duration summer club matches usually no more than 15 anglers , at the weigh in if the river is low usually only 2 or 3 anglers will have caught a Barbel , most are on the tip using baits that will catch Barbel , usually its the Bream that make up the winning weight , stick 3 anglers on the same stretch in similar conditions and more Barbel will be caught , I think the greater number of anglers , causes more disturbance and less Barbel are caught as a result . Anyway it matters not , you can't beat a good natter when your fishing , after all its not all about catching fish is it !
Just as well Mike😉
 
My local Warks Avon has had less barbel caught of late than the time I have fished it, seasoned anglers are still barbleless in November. But you live in hope and when you do catch it really is special. Never fished the Trent, and to think as a young RAF recruit I did my square bashing at Helmswell a stones throw from the river.
Perhaps even this old so and so might one day wet a line there.
A friend of yours Jon who no longer is a member on here told me you were the best barbel angler he has known. I know that as a fact, but you might even struggle down here. It's very quiet and scenic though🤠
 
Back
Top