• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Piling the bait in

Hi mike
I understand what your saying and agree also. What I'm trying to get across is that to make an out right statement of "piling bait in is wrong" or to say anything in nature/angling is black and white can lead to confusion. In general I myself dont pile bait in on a regular occasion(I have nowt to do with Yorkshire:D) but there are possible times where I love to fish over large baited areas. For me its all down to what I want,where I'm fishing and the style or approach of my fishing.
Hope my wording comes across ok:)
 
A few years ago I watched a chap on The Kennet put in about a gallon of Hemp, he was going to fish but was on call for his work and suddenly the pager went off and off he went.

About an hour later I went to his swim and peered over the bank to see 40+ Barbel feeding big time.

I had a gallon or so of Hemp and about 4 pints of maggots so I thought I would be able to keep the fish interested, to my surprise they started to thin out, so I droppered some bait in to see if they would feed again.
The upshot was these fish were so on the feed that no matter how much I put in I could not keep them, I simply did not have enough bait!
I made hay while the bait lasted and had 21 Barbel.

When I ran out mid afternoon, I started to fish single baits with no feed, the bites dried up.

Come evening and a mate turned up, so we piled in his bait, we had another 14 fish between us, when the bait dried up so did the fish.

OK it was in September, we were having an Indian summer and the fish fed for no particular reason that I could see, I do know that they fed again the next day and for several days after that.



A few years ago Mike Wilson and I under took a baiting campaign on The Thames we put in measured amounts every other day for about six weeks prior to the start of the season, once the season started ,every evening we fished, we would dropper out half to three quarters of a gallon of Hemp followed by two pints or so of maggot, we would then cast out a maggot feeder every 2-3 minuets to start with, slowing down a bit after an hour!
To say that we bagged up was an understatement for about a month we had between 3 and 11 Barbel each per session, granted we baited up accurately and fished accurately, but the effort we put in was well worth it, although the old bank balance suffered a bit!

As I wrote in a previous post, last week I fished a swim where I used less than half a pint of Maggots for 4 Barbel.

So the answer is??



Well I don’t know!! I’m still finding out how to do this stuff, it’s a matter of judgment isn’t it, after a failure or a success I will talk to Mike and others of the WBC as to the what, and the where, and slowly we learn to do this just a little bit better!

Problem is, there is no quick fix, no easy answer, what works today is sure to fail in the future, experience tells me that several Kgs of bait into water of 39`F is, in the main, a waste of time but sometimes people just have to do it, to learn it.

The trick is to learn it and not forget it!
 
Rob Swindells said:
Hi mike
I understand what your saying and agree also. What I'm trying to get across is that to make an out right statement of "piling bait in is wrong" or to say anything in nature/angling is black and white can lead to confusion. In general I myself dont pile bait in on a regular occasion(I have nowt to do with Yorkshire:D) but there are possible times where I love to fish over large baited areas. For me its all down to what I want,where I'm fishing and the style or approach of my fishing.
Hope my wording comes across ok:)
Click to expand...

I understand where you are coming from Rob . You are right ,there is nothing black and white with nature and trying to catch wild creatures . I sometimes imagine the fish rubbing there pecs with glee when some chap swans along and legs in a ton of food:) .
As regards maggots / hemp ,I think balling in loads of this has less potential to mess things up as they are nothing like as filling as a few kilos of boilies , they keep the fish interested , grubbing furiously , and losing caution as they become pre occupied , thus in theory increasing our chances of catching the blighters .
 
spot on graham.this pile in on small rivers is overated and not sensible at all.dare i say it.i have had some very nice fish on the single bait method.mind you i only do 4hrs max in daylight.
albert
 
Some very interesting views.

I did make a separation between particles and more substantial baits. Certainly some days the maggs and hemp etc. can keep the fish going practically all day when the conditions are right.

Certainly on some of the bigger rivers, a lot of substantial bait stuff seems to work very well in attracting the fish, although often feeding sessions are shorter from what I have seen as a general rule.

More concerned personally if it's loaded in, nothing happens, and when they do start feeding chances for any anglers then in situ are diminished. Even more concerned on the smaller rivers when it's practiced.

The bait gurus seem to make no distinction on this. Are they right?
 
I've been trying to find the exact wording to me from a bait company boss.

He said, words to the effect that barbel anglers use about 5 kilos of bait a month :eek:where as carp anglers use that in a session.

5 kilos a month? More like 24months!
 
I probably use 3-4 kilos of boilies a season for barbel and that includes me crushing up loads of it to use as loose feed.
 
Bait application is dependant on several factors; size of river, fish population (including the undesired smaller species), type of bait & angling pressure.In can be advantageous depositing several pints of particles in a swim in order to feed of the hordes of ravenous smaller species & allow the target species an oppotunity to get their heads down (not appicable in the colder months).However the same approach with larger baits or high protein baits, boilies & pellets, can in my opinion be counter-productive. This is particularly relevant on sparesly stocked, heavily fished smaller waters (unfortunately the ones i frequent).
Then there is the issue of fishing etiquette (or in some incidences,the lack of it).It can be extremely frustrating & annoying watching a fellow angler depositing several kilos of boilies/pellets in the adjancent swim & then waving the white flag after a couple of hours of inactivity.Anyway i'm off to liquidise several loaves of bread for a quick chubbing session on my small sparsely stocked river.

Regards

Andy
 
Hi Rob and others.

So would you agree a blanket statement. "When barbel fishing most anglers don't use enough bait, you need to pile it in"

Without some provisos, is pretty bad advice? There are a lot of anglers who believe totally what some of these sponsored guys say, and can IMO ruin many others fishing. One of them even says that middle sized pellets will dissolve in winter in less than 2 hours...so no problem!

The general concensus is................use you common sense. Conditions, river, flow etc etc rather than follow bad advice.

Graham
 
Last edited:
tommorow i,ll be fishing the middle trent with the roving approuch
30 mins in each swim with paste. hopfully find one or two.
as to filling it in at this time of year i think is reducing your chances in
getting a bite and have only done this when the water is thinning out and use dead maggots and hemp, 5kg of boilies never!!!
 
Hi Graham,

Overbaiting is a huge problem and it seems that many otherwise good anglers just cannot resist piling bait in. On rivers like the Loddon and St Pats at this time of year it's the kiss of death - I have hardly fished one stretch of the Loddon for the last two seasons because it is pointless, the other anglers seemingly involved in a competition to keep water levels up - and then they seem mystified when no one gets a bite for six weeks.......

The Thames I have found to be even worse and it is soul destroying to sit there, even in the summer, with a "fellow piscator" pulting out boiles for over an hour in the swim next door. I'm sure we have all been in that position, but has anyone ever caught following the bombardment?

I also seem to recall Ian Welch (in Phil Smith's / Stef Horak's book I think) advocating piling the bait in if he was unable to fish for a few days to ensure that no one else caught the fish!

Can you imagine if everybody operated on that level - or maybe too many already do?

To cut to the chase, if you are missing a trick, it's passing me by too.

Best wishes, Steve
 
It just demonstrates the poor level of knowledge that many anglers have.

When the Wye is fishing poorly I see anglers piling it in, I tell them that when the fish switch on they can stuff themselves and never get near a bait but it rarely sinks in.

Anybody starting out with a big bombardment in cold winter conditions are asking for a blank. Put a bit in and if the fish keep coming then up the loose feed, it all very straight forward. But as has been said, those with a financial interest can muck it up for others.

Unfortunately the vast majority of anglers don't think enough about what they do and are easily lead. Unless they have read an Angling Times feature about catching a winter barbel they will just do what they did after reading the catching summer barbel article.
 
Hi Steve. Hope you are doing well.

Dave, I tend to do the same as you pretty much re baiting.

Anyway. got it off my chest now. I was pretty fed up after watching the barrage the other day. Thanks for all the inputs.

I know theres more than one way to catch, but hope some of us can feel that the message is slowly getting through.

Graham
 
Angling experience tells you how much bait to put in : time of year, barbel population density, number of other anglers, water temp etc, but in the abscence of any experience, fishing singles in winter is a more sensible approach than piling it in. I fished a stretch of the Kennet in winter a few years ago which had a relatively low barbel population and was also relatively lightly fished. I failed to catch a single fish in about 6 sessions, which was entirely due to the fact that a sponsored angler was piling the bait in after every session he fished. The winter after, he'd moved on to pastures new and I didn't have a single blank on the same stretch (usually just a single fish mind) ! Sometimes it's not how many other anglers are on your stretch, but who those anglers are, that matters. So if you see an angler with a neatly folded T shirt, expensive camera, comb and a pair of nose hair trimmers in his rucksack, move on !

Nick C
 
Rather than move on Paul, it may be an idea to hang around for a while, all friendly like, and wait for the inevitable request to help him squeeze into his logo emblazoned T shirt and take a photo of him with his latest monster barbel - getting both in the frame can be awfully difficult you know !

Nick C
 
Nick
Rumour has it it would be difficult to get a full picture of you "au Naturel" and a barbel in the same frame....:D:eek:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top