• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ā€˜Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Mill Tackle no longer working with J. W. Young & Sons 😮

Good value? Suppose you'd have research and come to your own conclusions.

'Designed in the UK' probably translates to copied from other UK reel designs and images given to the Chinese engineers to produce something similar or they are already in a catalogue to pick from.

£150? If AD can manufacture their pin and sell it for £29.99 currently, is a Chinese made pin at £150 good value?
 
The main reason I've bought Youngs in the past is because they were British, and hardly any tackle is these days.
The secondary reason is how some of them look.
However, purely fishing wise , I prefer my Okumas.....
 
Looking at Roger’s latest post they are being ā€œassembledā€ in Tewkesbury by Chris Miles.

Bearing in mind they’re made on a CNC milling machine does it matter if that’s in China or the UK 🤷

My main fear is the blueprints get copied and JWY clones starting appearing on TEMU etc… which will 100% devalue the brand.
 
Glad i bought all the J W Young & Arnold Kingpin centrepins i will ever need over 10 years ago. The appeal for me was British made products to last a lifetime, also the Arnolds were made down the road from me in Wimborne Dorset.
 
I own a triton and river specialist, they are currently out of stock but available to pre order. If I was to buy others in future would they be Chinese versions of the same reel, but at the same English made current price? Thats my query. I dont need another Youngs pin or any other, I have a few that I got a couple of years ago and my shelf is full, but that wouldn't sit right with me if they charged the same price. It wouldn't necessarily be inferior but it wouldn't be the same, would it? I wonder if in future someone will find out what serial numbers the UK manufactured ones go up to, and the prices will reflect that on the used market?
 
I’ve met Roger a few times at tackle fairs and he’s a good bloke. I believe he’d recently started importing his own pins to sell and is now involved with JWY.

It’s a difficult one, really. Manufacturing in the UK isn’t as cost-effective as it once was, and plenty of high-end manufacturers have gone down the same route.

My other hobby, outside of angling, is Hi-Fi. My brand of choice has always been NAIM, a British-born company. They were bought out by the French company Focal, and manufacturing has since moved to China, with quality control remaining in the UK.

Would I still spend Ā£5k on a pre-amp…probably not.

I’m also into toolmaking and own a Warco lathe and milling machine, both made in China. I genuinely can’t fault the quality of either machine. The instruction manuals, however, are another story entirely 🤣🤣🤣

In my day job, I purchase a huge amount of metal-fabricated products from Shenzhen, many of which I’d wager most people on here use regularly. The quality is easily on a par with European-made products, if not better in some cases. Yet the cost and appetite to customise is much better.

For me, the issue with JWY isn’t necessarily the quality of Chinese manufacturing. It’s the fact that JWY has always been regarded as the pinnacle of British angling engineering. Moving production to the Far East risks diminishing some of that heritage, exclusivity and, ultimately, the perceived value of the brand.

That said, I can understand the commercial reasons behind the decision, and I certainly wouldn’t dismiss the quality simply because of where something is made.

And, if I’m being completely selfish, I wouldn’t mind being able to get hold of a spare spool for some of my reels !!!
Looking at Roger’s latest post they are being ā€œassembledā€ in Tewkesbury by Chris Miles.

Bearing in mind they’re made on a CNC milling machine does it matter if that’s in China or the UK 🤷

My main fear is the blueprints get copied and JWY clones starting appearing on TEMU etc… which will 100% devalue the
Looking at Roger’s latest post they are being ā€œassembledā€ in Tewkesbury by Chris Miles.

Bearing in mind they’re made on a CNC milling machine does it matter if that’s in China or the UK 🤷

My main fear is the blueprints get copied and JWY clones starting appearing on TEMU etc… which will 100% devalue the brand.

Gav I'll have to show you one of my NGT pins .... I changed the bearings with the advice of a couple of Chaps off here . I'm not joking when I say for £30 with the cost of the bearings they are bloody decent
 
These two reels appear to be virtually the same, apart from the colour. One under J.W.Young branding and the other under Holland and Wilkinson branding.



Checkout the back plate photos.
What's the deal with those H&W reels then? They look pretty nice for the cash with more than a nod toward Garry Mills aesthetics. Are they all true-pin reels? Bit of a mixed message from Youngs if they are basically the same.
 
What's the deal with those H&W reels then? They look pretty nice for the cash with more than a nod toward Garry Mills aesthetics. Are they all true-pin reels? Bit of a mixed message from Youngs if they are basically the same.
They are Roger Surgay reels I think Alan, I think H&W is similar to the brand he did with Marco Cortese. They are true pins but from china, so I think it proves the theory that Youngs are going down that route too seeing the new Youngs reel looks identical on the back at least.

I’ve said elsewhere, as a business decision in terms of money and a probably larger customer base the direction probably makes sense, but do they lose the heritage as a result? Think that’s where the negativity lies.

I think they need to reprice their heritage reels if the parts are coming from china rather than the uk though. I wouldn’t have paid what I did for my triton if it came from china. That’s really where opinions will divide I think.
 
If they are made under strict quality control and no compromise on materials there shouldn't be too much of a concern. But you 'pin boys are a demanding lot so your input would be crucial. It is however a sad state of affairs that such an iconic brand is gone east.
 
Re the Holland and Wilkinson brand, are they real connected people, or a made-up name to suit branding? A bit like when Tesco had the butcher’s branding Boswell’s Farm and all meat came from Poland.

If you look at the Holland and Wilkinson website, there are 4 different pins. They all look aesthetically pleasing in their different looks, but its basically the same pin. What is the point, when they are one and the same?

The website also states:

How We Source Products

Roger Surgay, the renowned tackle dealer, personally sources every product in our collection. He travels extensively across Europe, hand-selecting only the finest items for his personal stock, ensuring quality and authenticity in everything we offer.


So they don’t come from China?

I’m just struggling to get my head around what Youngs have done here, as it looks like a copy pin. Either that or Youngs designed both pins, but then there’s the big mark-up on the Young’s version!

As others have alluded too, there’s plenty of existing heritage Young’s pins already out there. People buy them simply because they look nice. After a few years in storage, they get moved on, so theres still good deals to be had šŸ‘šŸ»
 
Re the Holland and Wilkinson brand, are they real connected people, or a made-up name to suit branding? A bit like when Tesco had the butcher’s branding Boswell’s Farm and all meat came from Poland.

If you look at the Holland and Wilkinson website, there are 4 different pins. They all look aesthetically pleasing in their different looks, but its basically the same pin. What is the point, when they are one and the same?

The website also states:

How We Source Products

Roger Surgay, the renowned tackle dealer, personally sources every product in our collection. He travels extensively across Europe, hand-selecting only the finest items for his personal stock, ensuring quality and authenticity in everything we offer.


So they don’t come from China?

I’m just struggling to get my head around what Youngs have done here, as it looks like a copy pin. Either that or Youngs designed both pins, but then there’s the big mark-up on the Young’s version!

As others have alluded too, there’s plenty of existing heritage Young’s pins already out there. People buy them simply because they look nice. After a few years in storage, they get moved on, so theres still good deals to be had šŸ‘šŸ»

Seems like dicey water, if it’s the same as a Roger Surgay pin but Ā£200 more for a spare spool and JW Youngs label, then they won’t last long. If it was say Ā£225, with Ā£75 being the extra spool and branding it wouldn’t look so bad.
 
Holland and Wilkinson is just a brand name Roger created when he had ā€œDragon carp directā€ a British sounding name for the cheap Chinese tackle that he had made etc. when dragon carp folded he started buying quality second hand pins to sell on a facebook page, he has also released a book called ā€œfrom maggot boy to millionaireā€ apparently he’s a decent guy but he’s definitely a bit of an ā€œArthur Dailyā€ type though.
 
Back
Top