Joe Winstanley
Senior Member & Supporter
Does this perhaps suggest the 'Trentman' is a good value reel at that price?Blimey, that's not good; same reel !
The price for an extra spool and box on the Youngs example.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Does this perhaps suggest the 'Trentman' is a good value reel at that price?Blimey, that's not good; same reel !
The price for an extra spool and box on the Youngs example.
Does this perhaps suggest the 'Trentman' is a good value reel at that price?
Iāve met Roger a few times at tackle fairs and heās a good bloke. I believe heād recently started importing his own pins to sell and is now involved with JWY.
Itās a difficult one, really. Manufacturing in the UK isnāt as cost-effective as it once was, and plenty of high-end manufacturers have gone down the same route.
My other hobby, outside of angling, is Hi-Fi. My brand of choice has always been NAIM, a British-born company. They were bought out by the French company Focal, and manufacturing has since moved to China, with quality control remaining in the UK.
Would I still spend Ā£5k on a pre-ampā¦probably not.
Iām also into toolmaking and own a Warco lathe and milling machine, both made in China. I genuinely canāt fault the quality of either machine. The instruction manuals, however, are another story entirely
In my day job, I purchase a huge amount of metal-fabricated products from Shenzhen, many of which Iād wager most people on here use regularly. The quality is easily on a par with European-made products, if not better in some cases. Yet the cost and appetite to customise is much better.
For me, the issue with JWY isnāt necessarily the quality of Chinese manufacturing. Itās the fact that JWY has always been regarded as the pinnacle of British angling engineering. Moving production to the Far East risks diminishing some of that heritage, exclusivity and, ultimately, the perceived value of the brand.
That said, I can understand the commercial reasons behind the decision, and I certainly wouldnāt dismiss the quality simply because of where something is made.
And, if Iām being completely selfish, I wouldnāt mind being able to get hold of a spare spool for some of my reels !!!
Looking at Rogerās latest post they are being āassembledā in Tewkesbury by Chris Miles.
Bearing in mind theyāre made on a CNC milling machine does it matter if thatās in China or the UK
My main fear is the blueprints get copied and JWY clones starting appearing on TEMU etc⦠which will 100% devalue theLooking at Rogerās latest post they are being āassembledā in Tewkesbury by Chris Miles.
Bearing in mind theyāre made on a CNC milling machine does it matter if thatās in China or the UK
My main fear is the blueprints get copied and JWY clones starting appearing on TEMU etc⦠which will 100% devalue the brand.
Gav I'll have to show you one of my NGT pins .... I changed the bearings with the advice of a couple of Chaps off here . I'm not joking when I say for £30 with the cost of the bearings they are bloody decent
What's the deal with those H&W reels then? They look pretty nice for the cash with more than a nod toward Garry Mills aesthetics. Are they all true-pin reels? Bit of a mixed message from Youngs if they are basically the same.These two reels appear to be virtually the same, apart from the colour. One under J.W.Young branding and the other under Holland and Wilkinson branding.
![]()
James Young Heritage Deluxe Tru-Pin Centrepin Reel | Heritage Matt Green | Twin Spool
James Young Heritage Deluxe Tru-Pin Centrepin Reel | Heritage Matt Green | Twin Spool A timeless classic, reimagined in Heritage Matt Green. Celebrating over 140 years of British angling heritage, the James Young Heritage Deluxe Tru-Pin Centrepin Reel combines traditional design with elegant...www.jwyoungandsons.com
![]()
Holland & Wilkinson Trentman Centrepin Reel
4.5ā diameter hardened stainless steel axel machined from one piece of aluminium lockable and adjustable ratchet system line capacity : 275 yards of 8lb line 5 year warranty weight : 260gcentrepin.uk
Checkout the back plate photos.
Agreed. I'll stick with my early JW Heritage and two early Fred Crouch Aerials. Covers all my needs.If I'm honest, Joe, I wouldn't buy either of them.
They are Roger Surgay reels I think Alan, I think H&W is similar to the brand he did with Marco Cortese. They are true pins but from china, so I think it proves the theory that Youngs are going down that route too seeing the new Youngs reel looks identical on the back at least.What's the deal with those H&W reels then? They look pretty nice for the cash with more than a nod toward Garry Mills aesthetics. Are they all true-pin reels? Bit of a mixed message from Youngs if they are basically the same.
Re the Holland and Wilkinson brand, are they real connected people, or a made-up name to suit branding? A bit like when Tesco had the butcherās branding Boswellās Farm and all meat came from Poland.
If you look at the Holland and Wilkinson website, there are 4 different pins. They all look aesthetically pleasing in their different looks, but its basically the same pin. What is the point, when they are one and the same?
The website also states:
How We Source Products
Roger Surgay, the renowned tackle dealer, personally sources every product in our collection. He travels extensively across Europe, hand-selecting only the finest items for his personal stock, ensuring quality and authenticity in everything we offer.
So they donāt come from China?
Iām just struggling to get my head around what Youngs have done here, as it looks like a copy pin. Either that or Youngs designed both pins, but then thereās the big mark-up on the Youngās version!
As others have alluded too, thereās plenty of existing heritage Youngās pins already out there. People buy them simply because they look nice. After a few years in storage, they get moved on, so theres still good deals to be had![]()