• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ā€˜Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Mill Tackle no longer working with J. W. Young & Sons 😮

Alan Rose

Senior Member & Supporter
Just saw this on Facebook 😮😮😮

IMG_5928.png
 
I don’t know how I feel about the directions Youngs have taken, I did wonder when their new true pin with a spare spool was priced lower than previous, now it makes sense. They might gain more customers generally but they will lose the prestige and those that want British made stuff because of whose involved.

Kinda glad I got my Youngs pins a while back before this happened. Good luck to them but I’d doubt I’d buy again.
 
I see J.W Young are getting some stick on Facebook after announcing their new collaboration with Roger Surgay. I believe he’s best known for importing cheap Chinese pins?

The whole J.W Young concept in recent years struck me as being more of a sideline/hobby, rather than a full time business. This with the components made by Mill Tackle and then assembled at the Young’s workshop. When I enquired about a pin last year, I was informed that I’d have to wait, as he had another full time job.

Cant see this going down well at all, with both existing and new customer base? As mentioned above, they are already advertising a new pin, complete with spare spool for £350. They do however claim that the reels are still assembled and quality checked in their existing UK workshop. No actual mention of Far East/China on their long facebook post, guess they don't wish to mention this element. This will be a big problem for them, because as soon as China comes into play, people automatically expect a cheap pin of less than £60.

I also note that Mill Tackle recently posted on Facebook, not to bother sending Chinese made pins to them for repair, as they won’t touch them. Also included photos of shoddy components. Not related to the new Youngs pins, but was this Mill Tackle having a pop?
 
Last edited:
Mm yes I saw a post on FB from Roger Surgay new JW Y Heritage reel £350 including spare spool. With exciting news about JW Y to come soon. So wait and see I guess.
 
The new JWY Heritage reel says designed by and assembled by JWY in the UK different wording and font to previous reels.
 
I always assumed Roger Surgay was one of those completely made up names/a person that doesn't exist to give cheap tackle an air of legitimacy. So this guy is real then?

Nothing necessarily wrong with exploiting the Chinese market - their engineering has improved massively in recent years - but the price needs to reflect that. Even with an extra spool, £350 is still very expensive for a reel ostensibly made in the same Chinese enormo warehouse that makes all of those £30-60 pins that look the same but carry numerous different names.

This also potentially means that prices of used/old JWY reels on the secondary market might go mental.
 
Last edited:
I’ve met Roger a few times at tackle fairs and he’s a good bloke. I believe he’d recently started importing his own pins to sell and is now involved with JWY.

It’s a difficult one, really. Manufacturing in the UK isn’t as cost-effective as it once was, and plenty of high-end manufacturers have gone down the same route.

My other hobby, outside of angling, is Hi-Fi. My brand of choice has always been NAIM, a British-born company. They were bought out by the French company Focal, and manufacturing has since moved to China, with quality control remaining in the UK.

Would I still spend Ā£5k on a pre-amp…probably not.

I’m also into toolmaking and own a Warco lathe and milling machine, both made in China. I genuinely can’t fault the quality of either machine. The instruction manuals, however, are another story entirely 🤣🤣🤣

In my day job, I purchase a huge amount of metal-fabricated products from Shenzhen, many of which I’d wager most people on here use regularly. The quality is easily on a par with European-made products, if not better in some cases. Yet the cost and appetite to customise is much better.

For me, the issue with JWY isn’t necessarily the quality of Chinese manufacturing. It’s the fact that JWY has always been regarded as the pinnacle of British angling engineering. Moving production to the Far East risks diminishing some of that heritage, exclusivity and, ultimately, the perceived value of the brand.

That said, I can understand the commercial reasons behind the decision, and I certainly wouldn’t dismiss the quality simply because of where something is made.

And, if I’m being completely selfish, I wouldn’t mind being able to get hold of a spare spool for some of my reels !!!
 
My other hobby, outside of angling, is Hi-Fi.
Coincidentally I was about to edit my post above to mention that I'm a devout user of high-end digital audio players, and most of the current market leaders are Chinese. They've followed much the same route as previous far east countries when it comes to electronics - made in Japan was a joke in the 60s and 70s until they became the best premium in the 80s and 90s, at which point South Korea was the cheap joke alternative until they took over the markets massively in the 10s - and are still world leaders when it comes to high-end domestic TVs - and China are very quickly becoming well known in the audio world for their high-end electronics, at least when it comes to portable audio.

So yeah, I think wait and see how it goes at Youngs and in the meantime Mr Mills is going to be making his own premium pins which will fill the UK made gap left by Youngs.
 
It does seem a shame, although if they can’t make the business run without doing it, then who I am to judge.

I won’t be rushing out to buy any but will be interested to see what the quality is like in comparison to other JW Youngs and to Garry Mills own pins. I imagine they will feel cheap in comparison but we will see.

With Chris Lythe winding down, Garry Mills will have more demand than ever.

I’ve probably spent too much time reading Chris Yates and spending money I don’t have, but centrepins are as much about that special something than the practicality.

Some of them just seem to generate a slightly magic feeling, with the reel being predisposed to Wallis cast as per the users natural rhythm. Unfortunately I have found that seems to come from the more expensive ones. And even then, money is no guarantee.

For a lot of people, such indulgent sentimentalism is by the by or financially a no go. In which case, some cheaper functional reels of classic appearance will probably be most welcome.
 
Who knows what has gone on between them; at the end of the day, things change, and things move on... so best of luck to them all šŸ‘
I agree Ian. As for JW Youngs. Clearly they weren't making enough money just running as a sideline. Their customer base will change and I'm sure they are aware of that.
 
These two reels appear to be virtually the same, apart from the colour. One under J.W.Young branding and the other under Holland and Wilkinson branding.



Checkout the back plate photos.
 
Youngs are only doing what most of the tackle trade has already done…

British Fly Reels in Falmouth closed in 2004 and production moved to China. Prior to that they were taken over by Orvis.

Hardy and most of the top line fly rod manufacturers get their blanks etc made in the Far East; yet they still manage to sell rods here for serious money.

For Youngs the proof will be in the pudding - if they sell a quality product then they will be able to justify a high price. However if the product is the same as the mass market equivalents then their goodwill and loyal customer base will be eroded very quickly.
 
These two reels appear to be virtually the same, apart from the colour. One under J.W.Young branding and the other under Holland and Wilkinson branding.



Checkout the back plate photos.


Blimey, that's not good; same reel !
The price for an extra spool and box on the Youngs example.
 
Back
Top