• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

The 10%

Richard Hamlyn

No Longer a Member
I have been fishing for well over 50 years and where I come from the expression “10% of anglers catch 90% of the fish†is a common one that I have heard all my angling life so I naturally thought that it was commonplace throughout the country. Judging by some of the negative comments I have received since posting I suppose I had better explain to assist the hard of thought. It is not supposed to be mathematically accurate and down here we use it as a throwaway comment that is designed to inspire anglers to learn their craft and become one of the hypothetical 10%. However some people seem to interpret it as me saying I belong to some sort of angling elite which is ridiculous. For me the purpose of this forum is to share ideas and to help each other.

It is obvious from reading some posts that the person posting has absolutely no experience of what they are writing about and often they are only recycling some untruth posted by someone else that they perceive to be a “good†angler. The conversation goes something along the lines of “I have noticed that since the introduction of decimal currency the catches of Burbot have declined steadily on the stretch I fishâ€. To which poster #2 usually responds with “That is very interesting as I also have caught no Burbot since the introduction of decimal currency but I had not made the possible link beforeâ€. There then follows an in depth conversation between several posters who have only one thing in common; namely that none of them have caught a Burbot, in fact I sometimes wonder if they actually go fishing at all.

Anyway back to the 10% thing. I do not come from an angling family, but the desire (more like a need really) to go fishing was with me the first day I drew breath. It did not surface until I was about 8 years old when, while walking on Dartmoor, I saw an angler catch a small trout. I was spellbound and had to be dragged away kicking and screaming by my parents. Rudimentary tackle was immediately blagged wherever I could get it. “What to buy young Richard for his birthday†was a no brainer when I was a kid. Armed with said tackle and a copy of “Teach Yourself Fly-Fishing†I finally got myself attached to a brownie that probably went 3oz wringing wet. The moment I lifted the rod (a Milbro Truefly) and for the first time felt something tugging away at the other end hard wired my brain for life. In short order I also learnt that there was also a thing called coarse fishing and I discovered the joy of watching a float glide away and the magic of that simple act has never diminished for me. An endless stream of small fish followed before another pivotal point was reached in the form of a Tench that probably weighed no more than 2lbs. I may consider it a small Tench now but at the time this was a monster of the deep that pulled harder than a steam tug and started a love affair with the species that has endured all my life. I then became like an angling sponge trying to soak up everything I could by reading (I was far too nervous to actually talk to other anglers) and what I read confused more than it helped, because I took everything as pertinent to my situation, and this was definitely not the case. However I managed to lurch into adulthood and now I had the means to go fishing as often as possible and I was as happy as a pig in the proverbial. And then it happened, out of the blue, another life changing moment. I met a guy called Tom who suggested we go fishing together sometime. He was quiet, knowledgeable and caught fish the like of which I could only dream about with what seemed like consummate ease. There was no fancy tackle or anything like that; everything he did was so simple. Simple it may have been but he knew instinctively what to do, when, and where and opened my eyes to a world that I have been trying to join ever since.

The point I am trying (badly) to make is that there are a few chosen people who have a natural angling ability that I will never have. They exist in the worlds of Match, Pleasure and Specimen fishing and whichever road they follow is immaterial as they always excel. Anyone who ever had the pleasure of watching Ivan Marks fish will know what I mean, this man may as well have come from a different planet as me as far as angling ability was concerned. I have been lucky enough to meet others that are similarly gifted (numbering less than 5) and these wonderful people have taught me one important lesson, and that is that I will never be like them. Has this diminished my enjoyment of fishing? No, just the opposite, they have shown me what can be achieved if I work at it, and just occasionally I am allowed to experience their world for short periods of time when by a combination of luck and judgement I “get it right for once†and drag out a nice fish.

So there you have it. I don’t know if these guys are 10% or 1%, but I do know they exist and my angling life would be all the poorer without them.
 
Richard, there is so much to admire about your post, particularly it's ending. But I am also left confused and ever so slightly depressed. I mean, what have you been doing man? You have spent over 50 years looking to acquire greatness, to join the elite and yet you haven't made it. What's happened, and if you have struggled then what hope is there for the rest of us in the 90% having to take a meagre share of a meagre share of fish? From the very moment you drew breathe (I did that once in an art exam-totally failed as apparently it was TOO abstract) you have been an angler. When I first drew breathe I recall two thoughts 1) I probably ought to draw another and so on 2) Nipples-Brilliant. It's in your DNA and you might only consider yourself "good". If there is no chance of becoming part of the elite, then what's the point? I have got some great fishing tackle too, spent a fortune and had assumed that this in itself would get me most of the way there. Even Pippa M assumes I am an elite angler because of all my stuff. Jesus, what a mess. Next you will be telling me that the sea is like the land, only wobblier.

But then, what if I was taught by the great and the good and slowly but surely I managed to get into the 10%, the elite. And if others did the same then it wouldn't be an elite group anymore would it? Not unless we left it to the balance of nature to sort out. I mean, even the elite die eventually don't they so that would definitely help wouldn't it. Or, we could just recruit more thicky anglers, real numpties with weedy cheap tackle. Or Babies. I mean, maybe there are many others out there like you Richard, with angling in their DNA, there from birth. Can't we call them anglers too for the purposes of these statistics? They will be blanking for literally ages which would help maintain a balance and keep the elite 10%.

What a mess.
 
What's all this talk about aspiring to greatness in fishing? Had a walk along the river as it was getting dark and had a chat with an angler who was trotting casters on a small quiet river. He'd caught a 6lb chub and was dead chuffed. He knew the water he was fishing very well and had fished it for years, there was no one else around and he'd got out for an hour. A good bloke going fishing. What's with all this competition and stuff? Relax.
 
In my 30+ years of fishing the conclusion I've come to as to what makes a top angler are, in order: luck, time and skill.
You can waffle on about creating your own luck blah blah blah... but some people just have that Midas touch and could catch on an old sock in a puddle! You'll never convince me it's anything else!
 
In my 30+ years of fishing the conclusion I've come to as to what makes a top angler are, in order: luck, time and skill.
You can waffle on about creating your own luck blah blah blah... but some people just have that Midas touch and could catch on an old sock in a puddle! You'll never convince me it's anything else!

You are right Rhys...I have discovered the same thing in my 60+ years of fishing. Only in my local dialect, your 'Midas touch' is pronounced 'Class'. I have watched match anglers whose every move was poetry in motion, nothing wasted, everything practised until it looked the most natural thing in the world...a sure sign of class. Such anglers sometimes reach the stage whereby if they draw a top swim in a match, then the very least they will do is win their section....and frequently the whole match....that is real class. If they can work their way through ever better opposition and continue to win, proving that their early promise was genuine talent...that is top class. when they can do it week in and week out, finally reaching such a peak of proficiency that they are in the money most times out, and often winning from fairly mediocre pegs....they are finally getting there. They don't use old socks, they use the finest bait available, because that is part of their craft. Another part is being able to asses a swim with frightening accuracy, as is being able to adjust their tactics if they discover after a trial run that for once, their initial assessment was slightly out. Once they reach the stage where you can virtually guarantee that they will consistently catch the maximum a swim can produce on the day...that is called world class. When they prove they have the ability to handle pressure and carry on winning consistently against the odds, even getting better under pressure, anywhere and in any conditions...that is called world beating class.

Britain produces a fair few like that in comparison to some countries...perhaps three or four each generation....that puts them into a percentage I really don't want to work out. All you need is a truly outstanding natural ability, fine anglers around you to guide and drive you through you formative years, water craft second to none, a degree of dedication and a work ethic that demands huge respect, a temperament that is bullet proof...and fierce ambition. Combine that with ten or twenty years of practice two or three times a week in top class fields...almost bound to turn you into one of the flukiest guys around :D

Some specialist anglers are like that too, though they have the advantage of being able to mostly choose the time and place they fish...and are not required to produce at any other than their own pace, so the work ethic rarely is, nor needs to be the same...but the innate natural ability, water craft and skills are all there in bucket loads.

I have seen degrees of skills and water craft in a FEW carp anglers that would make you green with envy, absolutely superb, driven anglers...though some of you would never admit that that was possible :D:D

So yes...I believe in percentages. sadly, I also know where I sit in that rating :rolleyes: but then again, we can't all be winners :D And until fairly recently, I had a truly wonderful time just being happy on the bank....perhaps that is worth a few percentage points :p

Cheers, Dave
 
What makes life so bearable for the 90% is that, on a given day, they too can join the 10%. These brief moments take us out of the tedium of normality to heights that give us the psychological boost to endure the rest.
 
My brother in law is one of the 10%. We sat together one day and he was catching 3 or 4 fish to my one, we swapped swims, he still battered me, we decided to only fish worm, he caught, I didn't, eventually we both cast in and changed position, he caught I didn't, the only answer was to go fishing with someone else and leave the jammy git at home.
 
Yes Kev there is...

Sadly it seems some are only on here for the bite they can produce....:rolleyes:, which is 'not new' its self Kev...

It won't last for long tho, it never does......;)


Steve


Whatever the alleged motivation you have to admit it is producing a more interesting debate than the usual, "what (enter your own tackle item here)?".
 
Whatever the alleged motivation you have to admit it is producing a more interesting debate than the usual, "what (enter your own tackle item here)?".



No one forces you or anyone else to read "which.....? threads" Ade....

I'd have thought the title of such a thread would be warning enough as to its content and there for a warning for those offended by such post, not to read.

Also, as Andy the site owner, is happy to have such threads on BFW I don't see its anyone's but his business...

Steve
 
A stick will make a good controller float for those wiley carp and a stone will make an innocent looking ledger when chasing those pressured barbel.

Thinking outside the box is what sets the 10% apart from the rest of us mere mortals. :p
 
No one forces you or anyone else to read "which.....? threads" Ade....

I'd have thought the title of such a thread would be warning enough as to its content and there for a warning for those offended by such post, not to read.

Also, as Andy the site owner, is happy to have such threads on BFW I don't see its anyone's but his business...

Steve

All I said was that it makes a more interesting debate than the "which" threads. Where you get the idea from that I am offended by such threads I'm not sure, in fact if you choose to look back through some of those threads you will find I am a regular contributor an often chip in with my twopenneth.

Forums need people with fresh views to bring new ideas to the table, one might not agree with those ideas and that is what stimulates debate, surely that is the main purpose of a forum?
 
Back
Top