• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Otters.....man to sue EA

And for a flavour of what anglers are up against: "A seal eats fish to survive it doesn't catch fish because its a saddo with an empty life".

Just one of many similar reactions to the story. Totally unfair. My life isn't empty.
is that the weirdo swan woman again....:p:D
 
And for a flavour of what anglers are up against: "A seal eats fish to survive it doesn't catch fish because its a saddo with an empty life".

Just one of many similar reactions to the story. Totally unfair. My life isn't empty.

It's possible to be derogative about any sport or pastime. How often do we hear football described as 11 grown men chasing a pigs bladder around a field?

People who belittle others hobbies generally think they are being smart or witty, when in reality they are just displaying a complete lack of tolerance whilst also suggesting they themselves haven't the wit or imagintion to find an interest
 
I just hope the angling trust and fish legal are not getting involved in this farce!!
 
2) It's unlikley that the skeletons he found in the lake are Otter kills, i doubt that an Otter would eat Carp of that size in the water, they always drag a fish of that size out, and eat it on the bank.
Those skeletons look like they've been boiled ! in reality they've rotted down naturally, and not been stripped of flesh as he said.

The photo of the skeletons isn't of fish from that fishery, it clearly says so.:confused:
 
The photo of the skeletons isn't of fish from that fishery, it clearly says so.:confused:

You're quite correct Nigel, a case of me reading what i wanted to see.

I'll withdraw that statement, and replace it with another.

I doubt that those skeletons are of Carp killed by Otters.

I've seen the kills of Carp by Otters on one of the waters belonging to my club, and by the time the carcases are reduced to complete skeletons - a contridiction in terms - because the bones are scattered over several yards, by every little critter in the vicinity having a go at it.

Those skeletons have been reduced to that state by lying on the bottom of a lake for weeks.

Don't mistake my comments as being an Otter lover Nigel, i neither love 'em or hate 'em, those that are living and breeding from an original population ( i don't believe they were ever wiped out ) i have no problem with.

I am though most definatley the enemy of those a*$£*%!£$ who took it upon themselves to release them.
Also of those who continue to interfere in the natural order of things by building artificial holts, and rearing and releasing orphaned cubs, causing much suffering not just to the natural wildlife, but to the poor Otters themselves.
The so called experts of wildlife organisations etc who elivate themselves to expert status - THEY KNOW NOTHING :mad: and the EA for participating in such acts i would put in the same catergory.
They also for the record know nothing about flood defence, managing the enviroment, or nicking wildlife killing, and fish poaching EE's.
Going off on a tangent now so i'll shut up !
Except to say if this chap has lost any Carp because of nearby Otter releases that the EA was involved in or sanctioned, i sympathise with him, but it's obvious to me that there is no way Otters were responsible for the loss of 8,500 Carp from just one of his six lakes, no way.

The courts will see through him like a pane of Glass, and unfortunatley other fishery owers with future more genuine claims will be viewed with suspicion before they even present their case, and as i said will do anglings cause no favours at all.

I apologise for not reading the sub heading on the photo nigel, i'll endeavor to read more carefully next time ;)

Ian.
 
me think, he would need film evidence to prove this, and if so, with a good brief, think ea will settle out of court, mind you just seen the barclay brothers sue goverment for something like £500,000.000 and won,
 
I agree.Leave the seal alone! Some irresponsible anglers leave fishing line that traps and kills waterbirds.I`ve seen this myself.What if it takes an occasional duck?It has to eat.Bewdley will probably have a few more tourists who will come to see Keith!


someone clearly knows nothing!
 
Back
Top