• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

British Records vs. Moon Phases

For example: The website says there are 6 days of ‘waxing gibbous’ in September - so you need to divide the percentage of fish caught by 6; IF you want a fair comparison with the new/full/first 1/4, last 1/4 figures as they represent single days.

We do it by transcribing actual dates onto a moon calendar (28 or 29 days) and assigning a number to each day eg new moon +1, new moon +2 etc etc. Then you plot captures against the moon days (as per Stu’s ‘purple dots’) and look for the clusters.

IMO Chris Lyons was exaggerating what he actually knew. I had a serious argument with him at a meeting once because he claimed to have ‘invented’ the idea that the moon influenced fish feeding behaviour. He wasn’t impressed when I told him I had a book about fishing and moon phases written in 1936, that the Abu catalogues in the 60’s contained moon charts and that in the 80’s you could (and I did) buy moon data from companies in the USA (Viz, ‘Fish and game forecaster’).

Graham; if you read the data on the website mentioned it lists how many days are in each segment - which (partly) explains why the actual (single day) 1/4 segments represent less fish than the longer eg ‘waning gibbous’ (3 or 4 day) sections.

Without that data and the dates of the ‘unclassified’ fish, Gavin’s chart becomes fairly arbitrary.

In the days when Stu and I Stillwater fished together we analysed 3 years of captures on a local super hard gravel pit (60+ acres and less than 50 fish). It ended up that it was only really worth fishing on a handful of days of each lunar cycle (28/29 days). At one stage he held the lake common record (caught on a full moon day) and I held the mirror record. He might refer to it in Part 2 of the interview.
Very interesting reading - can you recommend any books or media at all please ?
 
Very interesting reading - can you recommend any books or media at all please ?
You best bet is to wait for Stu to finish his own book - that’s what he was referring to when he mentioned a ‘chapter’.

Then use the published moon phase/time calendars available on the internet to create your own charts. Make sure you get the times right as they obviously change as you go East/West etc.

As far as other sources go, there is plenty in America - bass anglers use moon data. The old book I mentioned is ‘The modern angler’ by John Alden Knight; it is interesting because it was written nearly 100 years ago.

Obviously sea anglers too - because of tides.

In GB, some pike anglers have written quite a bit; notably a guy in Ireland called (I think) Al Rawlings. He used to talk about ‘lag times’ and all sorts of ideas well beyond me.

Archie Braddock (RIP) talked a lot about the influence of the moon. His stuff is good. I think Shaun Harrison did write some relevant stuff too (and he was a mate of AB).

Chris Lyons used to write in the AT and each week he basically said half the days were good and half were not (based on the his idea that days round the quarters/full and new moons were good) - which is a gross over-simplification. As I mentioned earlier, on our carp water it was fewer than 5 good days every lunar month.
 
Chris Lyons was a BFW member back in the day, very knowledgeable I'm sure but it was his way or no way, he didn't accept any questions or comment against his views. He was banned from BFW as a PITA.
 
As someone else pointed out, there are numerous unknown data points that you'd need to know to look at trends with any degree of accuracy - weather, time of year, temp, bait, river levels and flow etc etc
 
I find this an absolutely fascinating subject and many years ago went through a "moon phase " phase which was very interesting and did, I believe but cannot prove, help me catch a greater proportion of big fish.

However, I did find it a double-edged sword and there was nothing worse than not catching on a poor moon phase day as, despite my desire to prove the theory wrong, the knowledge did drain away any hint of confidence I might have had. It's a bit like watching a dropping temperature in winter - you start wondering about what else you could be doing with your time and, for me, that's the kiss of death.
 
Chris Lyons was a BFW member back in the day, very knowledgeable I'm sure but it was his way or no way, he didn't accept any questions or comment against his views. He was banned from BFW as a PITA.
He was certainly a controversial character. I used to buy his charts, they were a fiver, and I once wrote a letter to Coarse Angling Today about catching a PB chub on what, according to the charts, was a grim day. To my surprise he rang me up the following morning and proceeded to rant about how I was belittling his findings. I certainly wasn't and told him so, but he still wanted me to write CAT another letter saying I didn't disagree with him! As Paul says, he refused point blank to accept any findings other than his own. While on the phone, after he had calmed down, he proceeded to complain that Steve Stayner had written that he found the moon charts useful in that he would avoid the red letter days as he always blanked on them! This prompted more outrage, but ironically I also found this strange fact to be true! I never told Chris that though :)
 
He was certainly a controversial character. I used to buy his charts, they were a fiver, and I once wrote a letter to Coarse Angling Today about catching a PB chub on what, according to the charts, was a grim day. To my surprise he rang me up the following morning and proceeded to rant about how I was belittling his findings. I certainly wasn't and told him so, but he still wanted me to write CAT another letter saying I didn't disagree with him! As Paul says, he refused point blank to accept any findings other than his own. While on the phone, after he had calmed down, he proceeded to complain that Steve Stayner had written that he found the moon charts useful in that he would avoid the red letter days as he always blanked on them! This prompted more outrage, but ironically I also found this strange fact to be true! I never told Chris that though :)
I agree it is a subject that also interests me as well. Having fished the same three or four weeks on holiday every year (usually on the Wessex rivers) for over forty years now, I have often tried to correlate catches with moon phases and have never been able to make any certain conclusions one way or the other. I feel like it should make a difference because of the impact of the moon on the tides and the significant difference between them depending on the phase of the moon. I have also read articles on how a full moon leads to more criminal acts and that the police recognise this. I believe that is where the term lunatic comes from.

It therefore should in theory affect fish and maybe many other animals behaviour, however I have never been able to correlate moon phases and with my own results.

This brings me to the conclusion that there probably is a small effect which is one of the umpteen other effects that determines whether you catch or not. Perhaps if you are a believer you will arrange your fishing around moon phase theory and when you catch it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Perhaps if you are not, you arrange your fishing to avoid the “best” times and that also becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

I suspect it is a tool that could be used to improve your chances as long as you get everything else right as well but in the meantime I will continue to check the moon phase when I get back from each trip to see whether I have managed to correlate anything.
 
It would have been Chris Lyons, as previously mentioned, he passed away a couple of years ago.

Not so sure about that. It was only last year that I had the conversation and the chap I spoke to didn't mention anything about anyone having passed away. So maybe there are others doing the same thing, but keeping relatively quiet about it.
.
.
 
Thanka
You best bet is to wait for Stu to finish his own book - that’s what he was referring to when he mentioned a ‘chapter’.

Then use the published moon phase/time calendars available on the internet to create your own charts. Make sure you get the times right as they obviously change as you go East/West etc.

As far as other sources go, there is plenty in America - bass anglers use moon data. The old book I mentioned is ‘The modern angler’ by John Alden Knight; it is interesting because it was written nearly 100 years ago.

Obviously sea anglers too - because of tides.

In GB, some pike anglers have written quite a bit; notably a guy in Ireland called (I think) Al Rawlings. He used to talk about ‘lag times’ and all sorts of ideas well beyond me.

Archie Braddock (RIP) talked a lot about the influence of the moon. His stuff is good. I think Shaun Harrison did write some relevant stuff too (and he was a mate of AB).

Chris Lyons used to write in the AT and each week he basically said half the days were good and half were not (based on the his idea that days round the quarters/full and new moons were good) - which is a gross over-simplification. As I mentioned earlier, on our carp water it was fewer than 5 good days every lunar month.
Thanks Tim - that’s useful information.

I’ve spent most of the day doing some digging on the matter and it’s certainly fascinating (to me anyway).

Great news re SM’s book - I’ll be one of the first to order it for sure.
 
I find this an absolutely fascinating subject and many years ago went through a "moon phase " phase which was very interesting and did, I believe but cannot prove, help me catch a greater proportion of big fish.

However, I did find it a double-edged sword and there was nothing worse than not catching on a poor moon phase day as, despite my desire to prove the theory wrong, the knowledge did drain away any hint of confidence I might have had. It's a bit like watching a dropping temperature in winter - you start wondering about what else you could be doing with your time and, for me, that's the kiss of death.
On the carp water I mentioned earlier we used the other syndicate members as a control.

I used to walk my dogs twice a day (most days) around the lake (it was 1 mile from my house) and interrogate all the anglers. I reckon we knew of virtually every fish caught over 3 seasons. It was a syndicate and ‘session fished’ as it was hard fishing - so there were people there virtually every day to talk to and find out what had gone on.

The result was that during the last year I fished there I was roughly 8 times more efficient (days/hours spent per fish landed) than the next most successful angler on there (Stu had left the syndicate by then !). Now I fully appreciate that I can’t possibly be 8x ‘better’ in angling ability - so the efficiency has to come from only being there at the ‘right’ times. Realistically it is more likely the result of NOT going on ‘bad’ days.

On low stock rivers with few or no other anglers that ‘control’ obviously doesn’t exist - so you either fish every hour possible, or just try and be there at the best times and then compare your results with other anglers that you know…..

One example; many years ago we were chub fishing on the B Avon and sharing car journeys as we lived in the same village. One day Stu announced that on a planned trip on a certain day the following week we needed to go in 2 cars. He wanted to go and fish for a particular barbel that specific evening on ano stretch. He reckoned that it was catchable at a certain time.

I rang him the next morning and he had caught the fish 10 minutes after casting out on the other stretch ! It weighed 13 +. Even more interestingly he found out later that several other big (12+) barbel were caught that evening on the BA by his other mates after a long fallow period when few decent fish were being caught by anybody.
 
All of this is all very well and I would never dismiss the findings of good anglers but if you are faced with one day a week to go fishing as many are and until I retired myself included why torture yourself? You either go fishing or don't.
Not convinced personally. If you tend to go fishing around your belief in certain moon phases then you will catch most of your fish during these times!
OK that may be simplistic but I seem to have done alright over the years taking no notice at all! Controversial, maybe. It's what I think though. I'm a simple kind of chap at heart! 😃
 
It's by no means infallible and of course there are no guarantees - thankfully! It's still the mystery and uncertainty that draws me to the river. I was surprised to see my best catches, modest though they may be, lining up on the quarters and until now had taken little notice of the lunar cycle, so I can't say I prioritised going fishing at certain times based on the moon. An unfavourable moon phase won't stop me from going fishing in the future if I'd like to go, that's for sure.
 
It’s a subject I’m fascinated in , I even bought the fishing calendar app to show best times to go / not go , used to get the old Abu Garcia book that shows 3 black fish = go fishing ! 1 black fish still go but don’t expect any records to be broke etc
I had my personal best Common on a full moon that was planned beforehand
Apparently on some lakes , bloodworm come out of the silt on a full/ new moon
Not sure if anyone’s noticed all the favourable moon phases have been on a weekend this year , not good if like me you’re retired and don’t fish weekends !
Having said all this I’ve just had a really good 48 hrs carping on a local lake , and it was a less favourable moon phase 😵‍💫
 
Many years ago, I was on the Bristol Avon with a mate and we came across what appeared to be every barbel in the stretch tucked under a tree on the far bank (very clear water). We fished together, taking turns to get position away from the tree, then feeding over the top. After each feed the barbel left the tree en masse, picked at the bait and then returned to the tree. In two days fishing we managed 1 fish each - very frustrating.

I had to go back to work but my mate stayed on for a third day. Conditions remained the same throughout but on that third day the barbel, still shoaled up under the tree, fed properly and my mate had 12.

Interestingly, a friend of a friend was concentrating on a different, low stock river. He had fished from 6.00pm to midnight, occasionally later, every night for the previous three months without a single take. On the day my mate had those 12 fish, he had three barbel. We also heard of many other catches up and down the country on that day.

I am convinced that the moon phase must have had something to do with it as every other variable was constant.
 
Does the phase of the moon affect catches during daytime? Have all the record catches identified by the data in post #1 been at night?

I'd be interested to know because while the moon is still up there during the day (unless you're a Pagan), we only seem to be discussing night-time fishing.
.
.
 
Yes, apparently so according to Solunar theory. When the moon is 'overhead' and when it's 'underfoot' are the prime times, I guess it's like breakfast and dinner! I haven't gone that far into cross checking times of catches on the dates but would be interesting.
 
Does the phase of the moon affect catches during daytime? Have all the record catches identified by the data in post #1 been at night?

I'd be interested to know because while the moon is still up there during the day (unless you're a Pagan), we only seem to be discussing night-time fishing.
.
.
Yes.
 
All of this is all very well and I would never dismiss the findings of good anglers but if you are faced with one day a week to go fishing as many are and until I retired myself included why torture yourself? You either go fishing or don't.
Not convinced personally. If you tend to go fishing around your belief in certain moon phases then you will catch most of your fish during these times!
OK that may be simplistic but I seem to have done alright over the years taking no notice at all! Controversial, maybe. It's what I think though. I'm a simple kind of chap at heart! 😃
Much as this subject fascinated me I never went fishing, or stayed home, because of the phase of the moon, and whereby fishing to moon phases will bring about self fulfilling prophecy there is no rule saying you have to fish by them. It is possible to have an interest in different things that affect angling without being consumed by them or letting them dictate when you go. Being an average angler at best I always found the grim days predictions accurate, but I used to go home wondering if I would still have blanked had it been a good moon phase day! By this I mean I didn't always find good, or excellent days too reliable either, but again that could be my modest ability playing it's part :)
 
Does the phase of the moon affect catches during daytime? Have all the record catches identified by the data in post #1 been at night?

I'd be interested to know because while the moon is still up there during the day (unless you're a Pagan), we only seem to be discussing night-time fishing.
.
.
The actual daily moon rise and moon set times appear to be as influential as the phase of the moon itself.
 
Back
Top