• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

British Records vs. Moon Phases

Gavin Burt

Senior Member & Supporter
Inspired by the excellent Stuart Morgan interview on Fishflix I've just gone through all x115 of the British Records and calculated the date (where known) vs. the exact moon phase (c/o https://mooncalendar.astro-seek.com).

The stats are thrown out a bit as there are x41 entries with no exact recorded date.

Summary as follows:
Waning Gibbous (18) = 15.65%
Waxing Crescent (16) = 13.91%
Waxing Gibbous (15) = 13.04%
Waning Crescent (13) = 11.30%
Full Moon (4) = 3.48%
Third Quarter (4) = 3.48%
First Quarter (3) = 2.61%
New Moon (1) = 0.87%
No exact date known (41) = 35.65%
Total = 115

Personally, I've never given it much attention, mainly due to the fact that I've always fished venues that don't allow fishing after dark.
 
Last edited:
Back in the late 90's, when I first started fishing the Lower Severn, I met a guy called Chris Lyons down there. Some of the more mature members on here my have known of him. He did so much research on the subject, logging details of the captures of hundreds of fish. He had his website called 'MoonStrike' where he would publish details of when was a good time to fish or not. You could also buy a year chart off him. His research went down to when were the good times on a specific day, based on moonrise, moonset, high orbit and low orbit etc.
A few years back we got back in contact, he was looking for someone to take on his hundreds of pages of research and transfer it onto a database. I don't believe anyone did, shortly afterwards he passed away. A great shame!
 
Inspired by the excellent Stuart Morgan interview on Fishflix I've just gone through all x115 of the British Records and calculated the date (where known) vs. the exact moon phase (c/o https://mooncalendar.astro-seek.com).

The stats are thrown out a bit as there are x41 entries with no exact recorded date.

Summary as follows:
Waning Gibbous (18) = 15.65%
Waxing Crescent (16) = 13.91%
Waxing Gibbous (15) = 13.04%
Waning Crescent (13) = 11.30%
Full Moon (4) = 3.48%
Third Quarter (4) = 3.48%
First Quarter (3) = 2.61%
New Moon (1) = 0.87%
No exact date known (41) = 35.65%
Total = 115

Personally, I've never given it much attention, mainly due to the fact that I've always fished venues that don't allow fishing after dark.
Inspired by the excellent Stuart Morgan interview on Fishflix I've just gone through all x115 of the British Records and calculated the date (where known) vs. the exact moon phase (c/o https://mooncalendar.astro-seek.com).

The stats are thrown out a bit as there are x41 entries with no exact recorded date.

Summary as follows:
Waning Gibbous (18) = 15.65%
Waxing Crescent (16) = 13.91%
Waxing Gibbous (15) = 13.04%
Waning Crescent (13) = 11.30%
Full Moon (4) = 3.48%
Third Quarter (4) = 3.48%
First Quarter (3) = 2.61%
New Moon (1) = 0.87%
No exact date known (41) = 35.65%
Total = 115

Personally, I've never given it much attention, mainly due to the fact that I've always fished venues that don't allow fishing after dark.
Are the number of days per annum each of those 8 segments represent available. Or are they all the same.
Thanks
 
Interesting, but the sample is small, with too many unknown variables (weather, temperature, season, time of day, etc. etc.), to prove that on the basis of probability the phase of the moon has anything to do with record catches.

That said...

... I heard a story about a chap who has recorded moon phase data for every barbel he's caught over 20+ years (thousands... a much bigger sample). He was once on the phone to the person who told me about this, when he interrupted the conversation, saying: 'I'll call you back, I'm just about to catch'. Ten minutes later he called back and confirmed he'd just landed a double figure barbel.

If he published the data I'd be first in line to buy it. Some of you might have heard the same story and know who the chap is. Maybe we should club together and offer him a sum he can't refuse, in exchange for the info.

.
.
 
Inspired by the excellent Stuart Morgan interview on Fishflix I've just gone through all x115 of the British Records and calculated the date (where known) vs. the exact moon phase (c/o https://mooncalendar.astro-seek.com).

The stats are thrown out a bit as there are x41 entries with no exact recorded date.

Summary as follows:
Waning Gibbous (18) = 15.65%
Waxing Crescent (16) = 13.91%
Waxing Gibbous (15) = 13.04%
Waning Crescent (13) = 11.30%
Full Moon (4) = 3.48%
Third Quarter (4) = 3.48%
First Quarter (3) = 2.61%
New Moon (1) = 0.87%
No exact date known (41) = 35.65%
Total = 115

Personally, I've never given it much attention, mainly due to the fact that I've always fished venues that don't allow fishing after dark.

My experience with a full moon certainly convinced me of it affect on big carp .
It's often said that big commons feed on a full moon and I put this theory to the test on a park lake in 2024

On the Morning of the full moon I caught several commons in the 20's and finished with the biggest fish in the lake at 29.8

It was enough to convince me there is something to the full moon phase .
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7723.png
    IMG_7723.png
    239.7 KB · Views: 57
  • IMG_7726.jpeg
    IMG_7726.jpeg
    478.1 KB · Views: 57
  • IMG_7728.jpeg
    IMG_7728.jpeg
    509.4 KB · Views: 55
  • IMG_7729.jpeg
    IMG_7729.jpeg
    462.6 KB · Views: 58
  • IMG_7730.jpeg
    IMG_7730.jpeg
    511.4 KB · Views: 57
Hmmm - I’ve just gone through x8 old photos of fish caught during the “witching hour” and every single one of them is a Waxing Gibbous moon phase.

Maybe there is something in this.
 
Interesting, but the sample is small, with too many unknown variables (weather, temperature, season, time of day, etc. etc.), to prove that on the basis of probability the phase of the moon has anything to do with record catches.

That said...

... I heard a story about a chap who has recorded moon phase data for every barbel he's caught over 20+ years (thousands... a much bigger sample). He was once on the phone to the person who told me about this, when he interrupted the conversation, saying: 'I'll call you back, I'm just about to catch'. Ten minutes later he called back and confirmed he'd just landed a double figure barbel.

If he published the data I'd be first in line to buy it. Some of you might have heard the same story and know who the chap is. Maybe we should club together and offer him a sum he can't refuse, in exchange for the info.

.
.
I agree, I've always looked at water levels and cloud cover before I go out fishing. Never given any interest to the moon.

Regarding your comments of the bloke on the phone - this is almost exactly what Stuart Morgan says in this podcast with M.Bowler.

He calls one of the Angling papers and says "...get down the river in two days time and be there before 8pm as I'm going to catch a river record double". And that's exactly what he did.
 
Not sure I understand what you mean ?

Can you explain and ill find out.
Graham; if you read the data on the website mentioned it lists how many days are in each segment - which (partly) explains why the actual (single day) 1/4 segments represent less fish than the longer eg ‘waning gibbous’ (3 or 4 day) sections.

Without that data and the dates of the ‘unclassified’ fish, Gavin’s chart becomes fairly arbitrary.

In the days when Stu and I Stillwater fished together we analysed 3 years of captures on a local super hard gravel pit (60+ acres and less than 50 fish). It ended up that it was only really worth fishing on a handful of days of each lunar cycle (28/29 days). At one stage he held the lake common record (caught on a full moon day) and I held the mirror record. He might refer to it in Part 2 of the interview.
 
My experience with a full moon certainly convinced me of it affect on big carp .
It's often said that big commons feed on a full moon and I put this theory to the test on a park lake in 2024

On the Morning of the full moon I caught several commons in the 20's and finished with the biggest fish in the lake at 29.8

It was enough to convince me there is something to the full moon phase .
My experience (with carp specifically) is the complete opposite . . .and that's after 40yrs of dangling for them! Full Moon = curse . . .the big common ting is a myth IMO. I intentionally 'miss' any full moon fishing as its the kiss of death for me . . . .new moon however is different gravy!
 
Graham; if you read the data on the website mentioned it lists how many days are in each segment - which (partly) explains why the actual (single day) 1/4 segments represent less fish than the longer eg ‘waning gibbous’ (3 or 4 day) sections.

Without that data and the dates of the ‘unclassified’ fish, Gavin’s chart becomes fairly arbitrary.

In the days when Stu and I Stillwater fished together we analysed 3 years of captures on a local super hard gravel pit (60+ acres and less than 50 fish). It ended up that it was only really worth fishing on a handful of days of each lunar cycle (28/29 days). At one stage he held the lake common record (caught on a full moon day) and I held the mirror record. He might refer to it in Part 2 of the interview.
Thanks Tim
Graham; if you read the data on the website mentioned it lists how many days are in each segment - which (partly) explains why the actual (single day) 1/4 segments represent less fish than the longer eg ‘waning gibbous’ (3 or 4 day) sections.

Without that data and the dates of the ‘unclassified’ fish, Gavin’s chart becomes fairly arbitrary.

In the days when Stu and I Stillwater fished together we analysed 3 years of captures on a local super hard gravel pit (60+ acres and less than 50 fish). It ended up that it was only really worth fishing on a handful of days of each lunar cycle (28/29 days). At one stage he held the lake common record (caught on a full moon day) and I held the mirror record. He might refer to it in Part 2 of the interview.
Thanks Tim.

So to try and understand, on the website for Sept it seems 24 out of 30 days are Waxing or Waning and on the records list more fish were caught on those dates than the 6 days of other moon stages?

I'm sure there is something in it. Just trying to make sense of the data.

I do remember that years ago when I arranged a charity fish in on the Severn for Gordon Scott the then BS Magazine Editor to get a bench for his favourite fishing spot, I caught a barbel that Chris Lyons said and wrote about saying it was impossible at that time.....I had 6 people watching me catch it!
 
Thanks Tim
Thanks Tim.

So to try and understand, on the website for Sept it seems 24 out of 30 days are Waxing or Waning and on the records list more fish were caught on those dates than the 6 days of other moon stages?

I'm sure there is something in it. Just trying to make sense of the data.

I do remember that years ago when I arranged a charity fish in on the Severn for Gordon Scott the then BS Magazine Editor to get a bench for his favourite fishing spot, I caught a barbel that Chris Lyons said and wrote about saying it was impossible at that time.....I had 6 people watching me catch it!
For example: The website says there are 6 days of ‘waxing gibbous’ in September - so you need to divide the percentage of fish caught by 6; IF you want a fair comparison with the new/full/first 1/4, last 1/4 figures as they represent single days.

We do it by transcribing actual dates onto a moon calendar (28 or 29 days) and assigning a number to each day eg new moon +1, new moon +2 etc etc. Then you plot captures against the moon days (as per Stu’s ‘purple dots’) and look for the clusters.

IMO Chris Lyons was exaggerating what he actually knew. I had a serious argument with him at a meeting once because he claimed to have ‘invented’ the idea that the moon influenced fish feeding behaviour. He wasn’t impressed when I told him I had a book about fishing and moon phases written in 1936, that the Abu catalogues in the 60’s contained moon charts and that in the 80’s you could (and I did) buy moon data from companies in the USA (Viz, ‘Fish and game forecaster’).
 
It would
Interesting, but the sample is small, with too many unknown variables (weather, temperature, season, time of day, etc. etc.), to prove that on the basis of probability the phase of the moon has anything to do with record catches.

That said...

... I heard a story about a chap who has recorded moon phase data for every barbel he's caught over 20+ years (thousands... a much bigger sample). He was once on the phone to the person who told me about this, when he interrupted the conversation, saying: 'I'll call you back, I'm just about to catch'. Ten minutes later he called back and confirmed he'd just landed a double figure barbel.

If he published the data I'd be first in line to buy it. Some of you might have heard the same story and know who the chap is. Maybe we should club together and offer him a sum he can't refuse, in exchange for the info.

.
.
It would have been Chris Lyons, as previously mentioned, he passed away a couple of years ago. He wanted someone to take on all his info, which I don't think would have happened. Sad really because he put years of effort into it.
 
Back
Top