• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

British Canoeing launches its clear access charter.

David Clewer

Senior Member
Not sure how the second element of the charter is compatible with their physical presence on the water, which must be harmful to the natural world on many occasions.


Dave
 

Brian Willson

Senior Member
Hi Guys,
I have just watched all the videos, what a one sided and pretty picture they paint.
Can you imagine loads of canoes on a shallow river whilst birds are breeding and fish are spawning, what about their statement saying they will keep the rivers clean of rubbish, I don't think so !
Can you image canoeists stopping and picking up rubbish ?

The so called Wildlife Eviromentalists have been concerned about the declining Water Voles and some water birds, and of course we must not harm the Otter by order of the goverment, also the spread of some invasive plants will be spread by watercraft along certain stretches.
The disturbance by watercraft in shallow water will have a big future impact.

Whilst river keepers and landowners keep their rivers clean and natural, the influx of loads of watercraft will help destroy it.

The problem that worries me is the goverment, can you honestly trust them to make a right decision.
I could waffle on forever, but allowing watercraft on our river is 100% a no no.


Brian.
 

Neil Smart

Senior Member
All the evidence you will need to prohibit free access is demonstrated on the Wye any summer afternoon. One evening on the Warks Avon this summer along came a long canoe with at least a dozen paddlers rowing to the beat of a huge kettle drum drummed by a woman at the stern. I was dumbfounded and said something along the lines of wtf!! They replied that rivers are for the use of 'everyone'
The local weir has a gravel run that used to be an important spawning area, not any more since the EA has put up canoe portage signs. The whooping and hollering is deafening do they respect the environment?
Do they .....
 

Graham Shaw

Senior Member
Another point is that more canoe runs by-passing weirs = more seals.

Those 4 months of seal devastation on the Swale this year were a direct and immediate consequence of a canoe run being installed at Linton weir
 

Nick Hodgkinson

Senior Member
Xxxx canoeists hate them all

about twenty years ago i rented a prime Salmon beat on the Middle Tay at Dunkeld, Perthshire

and canoeists from the Scottish University's were a Xxxx nightmare - there were 'launching points' agree with said Universities/clubs - but none applied on a day to day basis

they cut locks off gates and openly parked their minibus and canoe trailer where they liked

try to remonstrate and you were called a 'rich xxxx'

as the university name is on the van you try and ring the university chancellor - xxxx all chance of talking to anybody in power!

we then tried to ask them to avoid people fishing and taking a different 'line' down the river - again foul abuse about 'rich xxxxs'

and 90% of said students were ENGLISH not Scottish

and they were quite obviously from a very good background - plums in mouth (and yes i'm from same background but do not sound like them)

but its not just canoes/rivers - these xxxx disrupts deer stalking and grouse shooting as part of their perceived fight against social injustice (whilst they stay in a five star hotel on daddy's bill)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Paul Collins

Senior Member
For details, see river Kennet.
River Itchen soon to be diverted to make it a canoe course and destroying the Woodmill Salmon pool, as featured in the Doomsday book.
 

Dave Taylor

Senior Member
None of this comes as a surprise, .. the boaters/ canoeists have been consistently more proactive than both riparian owners and angling,..... you could probably add wildlife trusts to that as well.
Local councils,.. including mine are on a mission to open up rivers to the public on the basis that they are a natural asset and should be available to all.
With some exceptions,.. riparian owners just don’t want the hassle so don’t actively defend their rights but still enjoy taking the rent from clubs.
I live on the river and although my little bit of heaven is deemed non navigable above the tidal, it see’s plenty of boaters in the warmer months,... many happen to be neighbors who have obviously confused mooring rights with navigation rights.
Had a few strangers moored up and sitting in the garden last summer and have now put a beware of the dog sign on the bank for fear of being prosecuted in case my hound takes a dislike to those who want to treat my property as a public convenience.
I watched a boatload of drunks push a swan family off their territory onto a neighbouring cobs patch in July who promptly drowned two of the cygnets,... yet my council still uses “ the beautiful natural wildlife corridor “ slogan to attract more support for its public access agenda.
Sometimes it’s just plain ignorance ,.. more often it’s just that many are on a mission .
 

Stephen Crowhurst

Senior Member
This will have dire consequences for wildlife and cause land owners (as Dave highlights) a right headache, like someone knocking a hole in your fence and declaring a public footpath.
 

Nick Hodgkinson

Senior Member
Nick, please watch your language, kids read this forum.
sorry, but i assumed that as i typed the words no spell checker came into play so thought it was ok?

kids can hear anything i wrote on the BBC etc and far worse on You Tube etc

which words exactly were the problem as i cannot see my original post?
 

Neil Smart

Senior Member
sorry, but i assumed that as i typed the words no spell checker came into play so thought it was ok?

kids can hear anything i wrote on the BBC etc and far worse on You Tube etc

which words exactly were the problem as i cannot see my original post?
Actually Nick I used the same naughty word, and I thought the swear filter would work, it didn't I edited to ....;)
The word you used was .....
 

Damian Kimmins

Senior Member
I wrote to my local MP when this reared its head a few years ago and she (Susan Kramer Lib Dem) replied, 'granting open access has done wonders for Germany, look at how well they're doing in the Olympics!'.
It confirmed my opinion that you didn't need to be too clever to sit in Parliament, and thus there was no point in responding further.
Really, and I do feel this quite strongly, the environment in this country is well down the list in terms of it's importance to government policy, and feel that with the EU having provided a lot of the quality controls in our environments in recent years, it will soon get worse. The simple fact is that for such a small country England's population is just too large to maintain the environment to the levels we would like to see; it is the most densely populated country in the whole of Europe, and sitting 35th in the world list, 3 places behind India with it's 1.3bn people. Every rise in the numbers populating this country whether by births or by immigration sees a larger demand placed on the river resources here (not to mention other resources), not just in terms of needing drinking water and in the treatment and disposal of effluent, but also as a resource of enjoyment.
 
Top