• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Barbel by accident

Alex Gowney

Senior Member & Supporter
I was talking to a friend the other day and noted that I had only ever caught one barbel while not specifically fishing for them. It was in fact the first barbel I ever caught and it was from the Cherwell, while chub fishing. On the other hand I have caught a great many chub while barbel fishing. I realise it's obviously largely down to numbers of respective chub and barbel, but stretches of the Thames and, albeit far fewer, the Cherwell that held barbel, never produced one while fishing for chub. Has anyone else noticed this?
 
Yes. Exactly as you have described; I’ve chub fished numerous Thames stretches and never had a barbel whilst doing so. One I baited for months and had the chub ‘crawling up the rod’ - but no sign of a barbel/carp/big roach on that venue.

I did catch a barbel once when roach fishing with bread on a flooded B Avon. It weighed circa 6.5 - 7lb and was very entertaining on roach trotting gear.

I also caught one (a decent double) legitimately - but I found a plug and a wire trace in its throat…..Somebody would have got a shock if they had landed it on that set up.
 
Twice. Once on a lob worm when perch fishing in winter on the Wavon and once on the Havon when chub fishing but that was effectively a barbel rig with pellets on a very short hair.
 
Most unexpected barbel Iv ever caught was when out spinning for pike in the winter. I got into a fish and thought it was a strange fight. After a while my lure came up to the surface but couldn’t see a fish then noticed a load of line coming off my lure. I’d somehow managed to get one of the hooks on the bottom treble to go into a lead clip where the line runs through and about 5 feet below was a barbel attached to a rig. Was probably about 15 feet of line all together all tangled up that it was dragging around so lucky I caught it before it got tethered to something and died
 
When winter Perch fishing with lobworms on the Severn, I frequently catch Barbel. Season before last, for 3 consecutive Perch sessions, my first cast each produced a Barbel from near bank slacks. Pain in the arse on a light tip rod with 5lb line 🙂

Also had a Barbel laying on with a lobworm under a float, again fishing for Perch. The river was that horrible green snow melt colour, water temp around 4 degrees and landing net frozen to the river bank. I was actually questioning my sanity for fishing, twitched the lobworm back towards me and the float immediately sailed away. A real WTF moment when it surfaced and went 9.8lb!
 
My and a friend were fishing at Fladbury one random week-day.

He put his barbel rod out into the main stretch and flicked a perch rod out under his feet with a lobby on that he dug out the garden that morning, a size 18-hook and 4lb line.

A 15-minute fight later and he’d landed a 13.3lb barbel. I couldn’t hear him shouting for me as I was fishing the weir peg. He came wandering over out of breath and looking flabbergasted at his achievement.

It’s the biggest barbel he’s ever caught and that I’d ever seen.
 
Had many "accidental" barbel over the years, on worm when perch fishing, on wheat when roach fishing and on trotted maggots when after dace. It's surprising what you can land on a 13' Match pro with a 3lb hooklength!
 
The weirdest still remains from the Sopley Millstream (off the H. Avon) about 50 years ago! Freelining floating crust amongst a load of chub, it was 6lbs+.

I've had any number over the decades, mostly from the D. Stour and H. Avon with the vast majority while trotting a float with maggot, bread or tares targeting chub (or roach & dace).

The most surprising, and contentious, was even longer ago (1969/70). Again off the H. Avon on the lower part of Winkton Side Stream. Two barbel of similar weight as Sopley, whilst trotting flake/punched bread for roach. It was in an unofficial sweepstake match, I weighed in 21lbs+ for 4th place and a "bit of coin". But I had top weight. "They" only counted one barbel, not two. Both were weighed individually and returned rather than kept in the net. Deemed to be the same fish - such was the "competitive nature" of some of the senior match guys and me being such a shy and timid junior! I then came 2nd in the following Senior Club Match also at Winkton (19lbs 10oz approx 44lbs behind Dob Chislett's record breaking 64lbs of roach) but then won my first Senior Match as a Junior a few weeks later on the D. Stour at Parley & Redhill. Those were the days (6 months) after I left School and before I found a proper job!

About two decades ago I had a 3 day trip downstream of the main Collingham stretch of the Trent, had several barbel as intended on days 1 & 2 but switched to a waggler across, up in the water, after chub and roach but also had 3 barbel on the drop.

The barbel in my profile pic was 1 of 2 whilst enjoying a shedload of chub on Throop. Single maggot on #20 under a 10gm chunk of balsa. Had quite a few that way in more recent years.

No finer way to catch a barbel!

download.png
 
Barbel session turned Chub session, turned unexpected prolific Barbel session:

Around 1995 PAAS acquired the fishing on the River Teme at Ham Farm. I’d fished it a couple of times previously catching a few Chub and Barbel on float fished hemp and caster.

At the time I was in my mid twenties and took every bit of tackle I owned with me. Bait wise I had 2+ gallon of hemp and a gallon of casters (remember when they were cheap!). Separate trip to the car, just to carry the bait, in a large green Sensas groundbait bucket!

Fishing wise the day was a struggle, but I noticed several quality Chub coming up in the water to intercept the heavy loose feed. Couldn’t buy a bite trotting on the deck. In my rod holdall was my 11 ME pole. The top 3 sections were rigged with a 12’s elastic attached to a loop of 20’s elastic coming off the bung. This was my summer method for catching bags of Chub on my local river Dane.

I set the pole up with an on the drop rig to target the Chub in front of me. First put through with 4 ME to hand and I’m into my first ever pole hooked Barbel. Panic set in, but the fish was surprisingly easy to play and land with the elastic doings its job (6.6lb Silstar Match Team down to a 16s Super Spade hook). Next put in and exactly the same with another Barbel on the drop and so it continued. By lunch time a mate was standing on the high bank behind me and he could see the Barbel up in the water intercepting the feed! 30+ years on and I still vividly remember his expletives at the sheer number of fish present!

This was when we put Barbel in keepnets and by lunch time I was worried about how many fish were in the keepnet, so I emptied it. Had an hours break for lunch and carried on feeding. First put in after lunch and the madness continued…… No monsters just typical shoalie Barbel size.

Eventually I was too knackered to fish on and finished the day with 44 Barbel, 6 Chub and a Perch, all caught on the drop to double caster. To this day it remains my most prolific days fishing ever!
 
Caught my PB barbel when I was chubbing.

This season I have had 4 accidental barbel captures whilst carp fishing the river, barbel I am sure I wouldn't have caught if i was targeting them!
 
Back in the 80's we fished for years on the Cherwell trotting bread during the day for Roach and Chub on what turned out to be a good Barbel stretch without catching one. Then one day whilst trotting I hooked a Barbel that came past me in the river and off upstream before breaking my 2.6lb Bayer. As soon as we targeted Barbel in the evening into dark we caught them. I suspect that low population Barbel rivers are nearly all like this. Had Barbel from the Stour trotting maggot in Winter. On one very prolific Barbel section of the upper Lea I have had hundreds of Barbel trotting caster for big Roach whilst trying to avoid them in Winter. But the section has only a few large Roach and with -6 degrees and ice in the margins you can get 20+Barbel in a day. My biggest Barbel last Winter just under 16lb came whilst fishing for chub with flavoured cheese paste and 6lb line (very lucky). One thing I found years ago was I rarely got Barbel or Bream on really stinky cheese fishing for Chub. Though mild cheese worked well for me for Barbel.
 
I usually loose a size 16 or 18 hook to 1 big dopey barbel every winter.
I could gear up to ensure I land them but by doing so i would definitely affect the fantastic chub sport I have on the river.

The issue is our river is very slow, quite deep and at normal level its very clear. We have some gigantic chub in the stretch and they have been around the block a time or two.
Fine(ish) tackle small hooks and single small hook baits are definitely the order of the day if your to separate the monsters from the pack.

The problem with such tackle is it’s quite hairy when you do hook one but it’s man enough for the job…..until a barbel comes along. Like I said i probably hook and generally lose 1 barbel a year as a result but last winter i by some miracle managed to land one.
Spliced tip 15ft rod, 5lb line 4lb hook length on a pair of reds size 16 hook.

Barbel was a shade over 16lb 😂
 
Back
Top