• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Maun Valley Wensum Centrepin build quality?

Neil Blood

Senior Member & Supporter
I have one the above reels and use it when fishing 'big meat', its also a joy to use.

I do however have a couple issues with the build quality. The first one I received had a pronounced wobble and the reel seat, wasn't parallel to the drum, so it went back. The second reel, which I have now, also had a slight wobble and I believe over time it has become slightly worse (or perhaps that's just because I keep staring at it)? It also has a couple of machining scuffs, which clearly were not properly deburred prior to the reel being anodised.

I'm currently considering sending it to Mill Tackle (who built it) to see if anything can be done about the wobble? It doesn't cause an issue with the reel's performance and I didn't buy it to polish and put in a cabinet; however it bugs me that a £375 reel does this.

Any other owners of this reel, had any similar issues?
 
Blimey.... you wouldn’t expect that from a £400 pin
Get it sent back and express it’s the second one you’ve had with the issue.
Improvements can’t be made if the people aren’t aware of common problems.
As for burrs and poor finish that’s just total laziness. Massive pet hate of mine when people can’t finish something properly. Especially a premium product.
 
I've never actually owned or used one, but nearly every one I've ever seen on eBay has mentioned wobble, but also that it doesn't affect the reel in use. Seems to be a general issue with that specific model, as other MVT and Mills builds don't appear to have the same issue (or poor manufacturing for that matter). I don't know enough about the technicalities of 'pin making to suggest what exactly causes it or how it might be fixed, but if Garry Mills can't fix it then no one can - the man works wonders.
 
Neil
If you are in the vicinity of Redditch on Sunday 15th November the twice yearly Vintage Tackle Fair will be held. Garry Mills will be there so you could show him the reel and get his opinion.
Mike
 
Neil
If you are in the vicinity of Redditch on Sunday 15th November the twice yearly Vintage Tackle Fair will be held. Garry Mills will be there so you could show him the reel and get his opinion.
Mike
Good idea Mike, but Neil originally posted about this six years ago so I expect he’s sorted it out by now 🙂
 
Pretty sure I’ve made the same mistake!
Now I’m curious as to what happened to Neil’s reel 🤔
Nothing, I lived with the slight wobble and still use it. Also had one of the handle assemblies fall to bits whilst playing a Barbel. Fortunately all the components either landed in my hand or inside the reel drum! On returning home I dismantled both handles and reassembled with loctite! So you can add that to list on niggles too!

I corresponded with someone else who owns the reel. He discussed the slight wobble issues with Gary Mills. Gary said that it was difficult to build a wobble free pin, which doesn’t have spokes. Maybe thats just a true pin rather than bearing pin thing? I say this as I once owned a Swallow MK II pin. Spoke free bearing pin and that pin had zero wobble! In fact the smoothest pin I’ve owned and spun for 2+ minutes!
 
Nothing, I lived with the slight wobble and still use it. Also had one of the handle assemblies fall to bits whilst playing a Barbel. Fortunately all the components either landed in my hand or inside the reel drum! On returning home I dismantled both handles and reassembled with loctite! So you can add that to list on niggles too!

I corresponded with someone else who owns the reel. He discussed the slight wobble issues with Gary Mills. Gary said that it was difficult to build a wobble free pin, which doesn’t have spokes. Maybe thats just a true pin rather than bearing pin thing? I say this as I once owned a Swallow MK II pin. Spoke free bearing pin and that pin had zero wobble! In fact the smoothest pin I’ve owned and spun for 2+ minutes!

I know John Milner, who resides across the pond, makes solid drum reels, both true and ball race, and they don't appear to have any wobble.
John Milner has a few videos on YouTube if you're interested, Neil.
I know the Hardy Conquest reels were all solid drums, and the latest Conquest is also a solid drum (with large cutouts) true pin, which has no visible wobble, not visible to me, at least.
I'm certainly not saying Garry Mills isn't right, as he is a top reel maker, but obviously it is possible to make a solid drum bush and pin reel with no wobble.
 
There is an interesting photo " YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR" on the Mill tackle Co Facebook regarding cheap modern copy reels, ref repairs
that may be of interest. Also a comment regarding J W Young and Mill tackle reel handles.
 
Back
Top