• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

British Records vs. Moon Phases

I have no idea but very much doubt they were all caught at night.

I doubt it too.

The theory that certain phases of the moon are advantageous to catching, doesn't necessarily imply that the hours of darkness are the most productive during those phases. It may well be that the daylight hours are just as productive. Yet most people talk about phases of the moon - as a guide to fishing - as if they only happen at night.
.
.
 
There may be something to this moon phase theory but if you only go when the phase are at there ' best', as it were, you may well miss out on a lot of fish . I used to believe that the best time to catch Barbel was in the dark, but then it dawned on me that this was the only time I was able to go fishing . These days , no longer a work slave , I most often fish in the daylight and catch just as many fish even though I don't fish any longer sessions than i did as a night owl . Looking back in my diaries there is a clear trend of catching the most Barbel at ' Noddy time ' namely 30 mins either side of dusk , this is a pattern and occurs far too often to be coincidence , doesn't matter what time of year . So as the maestro Dick Walker said ,' first find your fish and second don't scare them away' ,once you have cracked that ,then just go fishing at noddy time with nice coloured warm water , ideally at the best moon phase and they will be a doddle to catch ! Despite what some anglers think, Barbel are not particularly clever fish , location is everything ,if they are hungry and they don't know you are there they are easy to catch when compared to many other species , however if none of this works , don't blame me .....[ PS I don't know why there is a line through most of what I have just written , probably because the mods think it cobblers !
 
Last edited:
I looked back to my last capture from down our way, a difficult venue at the best of times. According to google the last quarter was Sept 4 and moonrise was 10.37pm. The photo shows a barbel in my hands on Sept 4 at 10.42pm. I think there might be something in this..
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1697.jpeg
    IMG_1697.jpeg
    72.3 KB · Views: 71
Last edited:
It’s only happened again.. Frothing from moon-phase madness with it being ‘first quarter’ with an ebbing tide and moonset at 9.56pm in my locality, I feverishly drove to the river.

I was joined by someone who I told to come down because ‘conditions were perfect’ and we will be catching, he came down at took a seat on my unhooking mat at around 9.45pm.

I told him the moonphase theory and after a while he said ‘have you not cast out yet?’. I told him I’d wait 5mins and when I did it was an awful cast, not where I wanted it to be. 2 mins late the tip wrapped round and I was solidly in to a barbel..

Now if this was the Trent or elsewhere it wouldn’t mean much. But in this river there are many anglers I know that have never seen a barbel let alone caught despite trying, one for over 50 years.

I’m not saying this to big up my angling skill, the fish went 8lb 5oz by the way, just to demonstrate the truth of this wisdom.

Scott was perplexed annd I’m glad that he was there to see it. I sent the photo (a bad one) to my wife who I had told to expect a photo of a fish at around 10pm. Were were both laughing it was truly incredible!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1699.jpeg
    IMG_1699.jpeg
    53.2 KB · Views: 59
... I think there might be something in this..

I fished on Wednesday and yesterday. Wednesday I had my hook straightened by a barbel at 10.30am (lost it because I was too impatient and inexperienced), learned my lesson and caught a 9lb at 1.30pm and an 11lb 3oz at 2.30pm (my first ever double). Yesterday I had a 7lb at 12.30pm (fought like a b4st4rd) in the same spot. Both days were sunny, middle of the river, hardly any flow in the river, certainly not highly aerated water, no shade, and I caught all four fish at the 'wrong' time of the day.

I now have empirical evidence that if I go fishing at 2.30pm on a waxing crescent I'll get a double, first cast.
.
.
 
The theory that certain phases of the moon are advantageous to catching, doesn't necessarily imply that the hours of darkness are the most productive during those phases. It may well be that the daylight hours are just as productive. Yet most people talk about phases of the moon - as a guide to fishing - as if they only happen at night.
Correct.. The theory is that on the day of the quarters which happen 4 times per lunar cycle, there are two times of day that are majorly significant - 'moon overhead' and 'moon underfoot'. Obviously when the moon is underfoot it's daytime. The times of minor significance are moonrise and moonset and when these coincide with dawn/dusk it's prime time.
 
Last edited:
Back in the late 90's, when I first started fishing the Lower Severn, I met a guy called Chris Lyons down there. Some of the more mature members on here my have known of him. He did so much research on the subject, logging details of the captures of hundreds of fish. He had his website called 'MoonStrike' where he would publish details of when was a good time to fish or not. You could also buy a year chart off him. His research went down to when were the good times on a specific day, based on moonrise, moonset, high orbit and low orbit etc.
A few years back we got back in contact, he was looking for someone to take on his hundreds of pages of research and transfer it onto a database. I don't believe anyone did, shortly afterwards he passed away. A great shame!
I remember meeting Chris on several occasions in the early 90's on the Lower Severn.
Interesting guy who was well into studying moon phases.
Shame to hear he has passed.
 
I see Stuart was out fishing tonight and caught one not long after dark.
I had a 10lb 15oz barbel off the Ribble tonight within 10 mins of the sundown time, but i dont think that's the trigger he means..
 
I see Stuart was out fishing tonight and caught one not long after dark.
I had a 10lb 15oz barbel off the Ribble tonight within 10 mins of the sundown time, but i dont think that's the trigger he means..
I believe a lot of it is to do with the “mid point” between moonrise and moonset.

Yesterday that would have been about 8:55pm depending on where you are in the country.
 
Back
Top