• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

How important is it to be accurate when prebaiting and fishing?

Steve Quinn

Senior Member
And is it important?

Okay so we know how obsessed carp anglers are with getting their spomb and rig 'on the spot' at distance. Just wondering if you barbel anglers do the same and your thoughts on it. Obviously a lot of barbel angling is done on small to medium rivers, or a underarm swing so its easy to do all that without clipping-up or using distance sticks, or using other methods of marking the spot and getting everything super accurate. To be honest it's one of the reasons when I go carp fishing (rare) that I just fish the margins and go stalking. All of that faff does not appeal to me, especially with multiple rods. To me it's a brain drain. But say if you are fishing The Thames and your spot is three quarters across. Would you go to the effort of using carp tactics to make everything 'spot-on'? Night time is obviously the problem, just using eyes isn't happening really, unless shining a bright beam of light across the river. Just wondered what you think. I only use one rod and have been thinking perhaps I should start employing these methods with my bopper for prebaiting and rig when fishing. My results have been rather good (can't say too much) but maybe I should up the ante and get better, instead of chucking and chancing it. I always say to myself 'Quinny, they are fish, they have fins and they swim! And they will find it, don't fret too much about it.' What do you think?
 
Last edited:
Steve. I have never fished like that for Carp. I do own Spombs though I haven't used one for years. Surely the fish get used to the little piles of bait and it could be a warning sign? I much prefer to spread my bait about and get them searching for it. I believe they are easier to hook as well as they move from bait to bait.
With Barbel though I often use a bait dropper I will try and have bits of boilie or pellet spread around the main baited area. Again I believe it encourages them to move around searching. It also becomes less critical to place your bait exactly on top of a tight area. Just as well in my case! 😀
 
Steve. I have never fished like that for Carp. I do own Spombs though I haven't used one for years. Surely the fish get used to the little piles of bait and it could be a warning sign? I much prefer to spread my bait about and get them searching for it. I believe they are easier to hook as well as they move from bait to bait.
With Barbel though I often use a bait dropper I will try and have bits of boilie or pellet spread around the main baited area. Again I believe it encourages them to move around searching. It also becomes less critical to place your bait exactly on top of a tight area. Just as well in my case! 😀
It is rare that I fish more than 80 yards out for Carp. Usually far less. Anywhere involving long chucks I don't fish. I don’t enjoy it. Each to his or her own.
 
I do on the Trent - as a carp angler for the majority of the season I'm used to wrapping out at different distances with sticks etc so do the same based on it being a larger expanse of water . . .perspective can be deceiving at longer ranges so would rather be accurate than not . . .especially if I've found / am fishing to a feature (eg depression / gravel seam / weedbed / snag etc). Smaller rivers I don't usually bother as its difficult to not be accurate with an underarm chuck . . .saying that I have been known to do it with a maggot feeder as accuracy and consistency are key in this instance IMO . . .rather than sticks I'll use marker braid or a small sliver of electrical tape to mark the distance and enable consistent clipping up etc . . .
 
Barbel swim about , if you want to use an attractant near your hook bait use a swim feeder . If Barbel are in the swim and feeding they will find your bait , a couple of yards ' out ' in you casting I don't believe will make a jot of difference , however if you are fishing to a feature , ie a weed bed , overhanging tree , then obviously casting near it may be more important . If you believe that pre baiting helps then in my view casting your hook bait in the general area will suffice . I am of the opinion pre baiting for barbel is a waste of time and money , there are endless videos on you tube of anglers piling in lots of free offerings with catapults , spods etc , surely all this does is fill the fish up with food and your boilie or pellet is on the river bed with 50 or more other bits of food scattered around it , you could argue that this reduces your chance of hooking a fish ? I can see some logic in putting in attractants like hemp or maggots which arent filling but beyond that all it does is make the angler believe that he is increasing his chances of catching a Barbel . One could argue that regular pre baiting in the same area will teach fish that it is a good place to come for a feed , however pre baiting also attracts lots of other fish , I am particularly thinking of Bream which can be a pain and push out the Barbel . I largely fish the Yorkshire Ouse for Barbel , this is a big spate river , I have fished it in huge floods [ 12ft + of extra water ] no pre baiting , no swim feeder , just a large smelly bait and don't struggle to catch Barbel , finding a big lump of spam even in these conditions is not hard for Barbel . BUT if pre baiting gives you confidence , then go ahead , the worst you can do is catch some Bream with the added bonus of making the Barbel bigger and fatter !
 
Barbel swim about , if you want to use an attractant near your hook bait use a swim feeder . If Barbel are in the swim and feeding they will find your bait , a couple of yards ' out ' in you casting I don't believe will make a jot of difference , however if you are fishing to a feature , ie a weed bed , overhanging tree , then obviously casting near it may be more important . If you believe that pre baiting helps then in my view casting your hook bait in the general area will suffice . I am of the opinion pre baiting for barbel is a waste of time and money , there are endless videos on you tube of anglers piling in lots of free offerings with catapults , spods etc , surely all this does is fill the fish up with food and your boilie or pellet is on the river bed with 50 or more other bits of food scattered around it , you could argue that this reduces your chance of hooking a fish ? I can see some logic in putting in attractants like hemp or maggots which arent filling but beyond that all it does is make the angler believe that he is increasing his chances of catching a Barbel . One could argue that regular pre baiting in the same area will teach fish that it is a good place to come for a feed , however pre baiting also attracts lots of other fish , I am particularly thinking of Bream which can be a pain and push out the Barbel . I largely fish the Yorkshire Ouse for Barbel , this is a big spate river , I have fished it in huge floods [ 12ft + of extra water ] no pre baiting , no swim feeder , just a large smelly bait and don't struggle to catch Barbel , finding a big lump of spam even in these conditions is not hard for Barbel . BUT if pre baiting gives you confidence , then go ahead , the worst you can do is catch some Bream with the added bonus of making the Barbel bigger and fatter !
I agree with much of that Mike though would say that maybe the worst you can do, particularly in winter, is ruin, not only your own, but everyone else's fishing. 👍
 
There seems to be a growing trend among barbel anglers on the Trent to use distance sticks and clip up. There may well be something in it, but I’ve yet to be convinced that the benefits justify the extra hassle.
 
The prebaiting is defiantly working. Well. The question was more about having almost perfect accuracy instead of blind casting at night, two thirds across The Thames.
 
You need to take into account that the flow is going to take some of the bait so it won’t be like pre baiting a spot on a lake where your bait is going to pretty much stay where you drop it and is only going to move about if fish start grubbing about in it.
 
I’ve been trying to avoid the bream while fishing the Trent and in this case it’s a big chuck across to the far side so on my last visit which was on Monday i fished two rods throughout the afternoon and night, I put some boilies 80+ on the upstream spot fairly accurately not clipped up so spread about a little with a mini spopper then used a open ended feeder on the upstream rod with mixed pellets broken boilies plugged with ground bait cast frequently and just used pva mesh bags with a dozen 14mm boilies on a pva swivel and lead each cast on the down stream rod which was cast across on the same line, the end result was 1 barbel and over a 100lb of bream on the upstream rod and 2 barbel on the downstream rod with no bream. My friend who was fishing above me catapulted around half a kilo of boilies scattered around a larger area and used open ended feeders with pellets and ground bait on both rods and caught 1 barbel and around 200lb of bream! so based on those results I’ll be trying this again (pva mesh bags) on both rods and will drop the heavier baiting approach which definitely increases the chances of catching the bream imo.
 
As for pre-baiting on days when not fishing, I wouldn’t know if it’s worth it? But would think it important to do it regularly ie every other day or so for it to work?
 
I always thought pre-baiting was pointless because when you get to the river then next day someone else might have bagged your swim.

But it also doesn't 'feel' right to me. The whole point of river fishing (for me) is that you have to try to figure out where the fish might be, try to entice them into your swim, and if necessary move and repeat.

I'm no expert, but I either use no loose feed at all (treat 'em mean, keep 'em keen), or PVA bags on the first few casts, with a little loose feed thereafter. All guesswork (and not particularly educated, in my case), but probably more reliable than pre-baiting and more accurate with bigger chucks on larger rivers.

I'll never forget that my first barbel was on a pair on maggots, after having spent £40.00 that morning on all kinds of exotic baits. The joy of fishing is not knowing exactly what's going on under the water, and what you're going to catch and how. Pre-baiting seems to go against that.
.
.
 
Barbel swim about , if you want to use an attractant near your hook bait use a swim feeder . If Barbel are in the swim and feeding they will find your bait , a couple of yards ' out ' in you casting I don't believe will make a jot of difference , however if you are fishing to a feature , ie a weed bed , overhanging tree , then obviously casting near it may be more important . If you believe that pre baiting helps then in my view casting your hook bait in the general area will suffice . I am of the opinion pre baiting for barbel is a waste of time and money , there are endless videos on you tube of anglers piling in lots of free offerings with catapults , spods etc , surely all this does is fill the fish up with food and your boilie or pellet is on the river bed with 50 or more other bits of food scattered around it , you could argue that this reduces your chance of hooking a fish ? I can see some logic in putting in attractants like hemp or maggots which arent filling but beyond that all it does is make the angler believe that he is increasing his chances of catching a Barbel . One could argue that regular pre baiting in the same area will teach fish that it is a good place to come for a feed , however pre baiting also attracts lots of other fish , I am particularly thinking of Bream which can be a pain and push out the Barbel . I largely fish the Yorkshire Ouse for Barbel , this is a big spate river , I have fished it in huge floods [ 12ft + of extra water ] no pre baiting , no swim feeder , just a large smelly bait and don't struggle to catch Barbel , finding a big lump of spam even in these conditions is not hard for Barbel . BUT if pre baiting gives you confidence , then go ahead , the worst you can do is catch some Bream with the added bonus of making the Barbel bigger and fatter !
The one and only time I've multi-day pre-baited a river swim was about 18-20yrs ago on the Teme. I fashioned myself a virgin 'swim', well hidden behind brambles/balsam, then introduced home made Supermilk boilies at about noon for 5 or 6 days.
On the 7th day I fished it .... and caught bream, bream, and more snotty bream...but not a single barbel.
Although I'd previously had several hundred barbel from that stretch, I'd never had a bream from there before. Or since.
I've not multi-day pre-baited a river since. 😂
 
I have been fortunate enough to actually watch the reactions of barbel over introduced feed this season on a nearbank gravel bed.Very instructive if frustrating.I used a baitdropper to deposit hemp and mixed pellets into the run.Obviously could not see the hemp on the bottom but the pellets were in small piles.A hoard of small fish were over the pellets immediately displacing some to trickle down the swim but as soon as the barbel moved in they approached the piles of bait with caution and would spook away from them,however the water displacement of their taifin scattered the piles and pellets ended up all down the run.Only then did they appear to be confidently feeding when the feed was scattered.They still seemed to avoid the pellets attached to a hook though.!Tried a method feeder with no loosefeed,they would drift over it but weren't interested.
 
There seems to be a growing trend among barbel anglers on the Trent to use distance sticks and clip up. There may well be something in it, but I’ve yet to be convinced that the benefits justify the extra hassle.
10 wraps (40yds) and anything under this takes no more than 30secs; hardly a chore even if your recasting every 20mins . . !
 
10 wraps (40yds) and anything under this takes no more than 30secs; hardly a chore even if your recasting every 20mins . . !
I've had bigger chores, I'll agree:). I can see the advantage of precise casting when fishing tight to a feature, although there aren't too many of those in the boat channel on the Trent. But in relatively featureless open water, what advantage do you feel it gives you over someone spreading their feed across a 10ft square area at 40 yards?
 
I've had bigger chores, I'll agree:). I can see the advantage of precise casting when fishing tight to a feature, although there aren't too many of those in the boat channel on the Trent. But in relatively featureless open water, what advantage do you feel it gives you over someone spreading their feed across a 10ft square area at 40 yards?
Fair point but other than the boat channel I'm always looking for gravel seams on the Trent as these are where I've had most success . . .I also like to fish both rods in a straight line to each other (upstream / downstream) so at 40yds (which is arguably beyond the Trent limit without backleads / boat agg) the accuracy helps . . .its weird because I'm a massive advocate of spread baiting when carp fishing but just think that (in my head anyway) a trail of bait in a line or maybe two lines in running water leading directly to my hookbait presents a more effective solution. That and the fact that wrapping up makes 'me' and my OCD feel a whole lot better / provides confidence over simply pub chucking . . !
 
I’m looking for a location that has a change in depth in an area I’m confident of being able to consistently feed and cast to which means it won’t be more than 30 yards and nearer the better. I like areas just below where rivers have narrowed which is good for fish holding and means the rivers more manageable to approach, as well as an inside crease or slack, bends which I’ll choose to be on the right side of. A spot 3/4 of the way across a big river I’ll aim to fish from the other side, or find somewhere else. Needing to have a rod tip high in the air is probably a sign that I could have chosen a better swim unless it’s really piling through. The likelihood of feeding and fishing inaccurately and ineffectively at range is much greater. Some people are blessed with phenomenal accuracy at range, like the challenge and have the desire to use distance sticks but that’s not me. Anglers often seem obsessed with the far bank when the near will do!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top