• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Why?

Paul Bullinger

Senior Member & Supporter
I am fishing the River Severn for a few days with some mates. We are "old school".
We don't discard line, drink cans, empty meat tins etc. We take it down to the river and, after our session, we take it back to the car to be disposed of properly.
Why oh why oh why do other anglers leave all their rubbish in the swim?
I genuinely don't understand it. It can't do with weight as an empty can of meat weighs less than a full can!
Answers please on a postcard to BAA!
 
I am fishing the River Severn for a few days with some mates. We are "old school".
We don't discard line, drink cans, empty meat tins etc. We take it down to the river and, after our session, we take it back to the car to be disposed of properly.
Why oh why oh why do other anglers leave all their rubbish in the swim?
I genuinely don't understand it. It can't do with weight as an empty can of meat weighs less than a full can!
Answers please on a postcard to BAA!
People are just absolute scum!!! Always have a rubbish bag in my gear,just don't get the mentality of these complete dickheads 🤬
 
As a bailiff for the B.A.A it’s the one things that really annoys me, when I’m out I always make the anglers aware they are responsible for there pegs any rubbish they pick it up !!
Yes a lot ARE anglers but you also get walkers leaving there cans and rubbish behind no excuses just total scumbags in my eyes .
 
As a bailiff for the B.A.A it’s the one things that really annoys me, when I’m out I always make the anglers aware they are responsible for there pegs any rubbish they pick it up !!
Yes a lot ARE anglers but you also get walkers leaving there cans and rubbish behind no excuses just total scumbags in my eyes .
You shouldn't have to make anglers aware if they were decent human beings, unfortunately some are not 🙄
 
i honestly think it’s kids , many a time on the bristol avon i’ve picked up all kinds of litter , bait wrappers , discarded line , beer cans , little poly weed bags . it can’t be “real” anglers , because whoever is leaving the mess has no respect for the river / wildlife and environment .
 
I'd be interested to know if this is as big a problem on waters where the membership costs more than BAA. I never used to see litter when I was fly fishing in north Wales and the subs were £150.00 per annum.

When the subs are low a club can't but help attract the scumbag contingent and I'd pay more if it cleared the swamp, but the idea of pricing out the scum is enough to send committee members into paroxysms of outrage. So nothing changes.
.
.
 
I'd be interested to know if this is as big a problem on waters where the membership costs more than BAA. I never used to see litter when I was fly fishing in north Wales and the subs were £150.00 per annum.

When the subs are low a club can't but help attract the scumbag contingent and I'd pay more if it cleared the swamp, but the idea of pricing out the scum is enough to send committee members into paroxysms of outrage. So nothing changes.
.
.
Wow! So you’re basically saying that people with a lower income are scumbags and people with money are righteous citizens.
 
Wow! So you’re basically saying that people with a lower income are scumbags and people with money are righteous citizens.

No, I'm not saying that at all, so you can get off your soap box.

I'm saying that, for a lot of people, if they get something for next to nothing they place a low value on it and don't respect or cherish it.

It's funny how, regardless of income, everyone seems able and willing to buy a smart phone, without grumbling about the obscene profits Samsung and Apple are making. Yet when it comes to paying more than £45.00 for an annual fishing permit they cry discrimination against those on low incomes.

Society has its priorities wrong.
.
.
 
No, I'm not saying that at all, so you can get off your soap box.

I'm saying that, for a lot of people, if they get something for next to nothing they place a low value on it and don't respect or cherish it.

It's funny how, regardless of income, everyone seems able and willing to buy a smart phone, without grumbling about the obscene profits Samsung and Apple are making. Yet when it comes to paying more than £45.00 for an annual fishing permit they cry discrimination against those on low incomes.

Society has its priorities wrong.
.
.
I’m not on a soap box.Just making an observation.I still think you’re being very judgemental but agree that it is a big problem and not just on river banks.It depresses me very much.
 
One solution might be to make the anglers responsible for any litter in their swim. Harsh and needs to be bailiffed appropriately but it can work, especially if repeat offenders are threatened with losing their membership.


Dave
RDAA (Reading) used to employ (and enforce) that rule. Their waters were always immaculate. It required strong baliffing.

I absolutely abhor litter and even pick up stuff when I’m walking my dog. It is interesting that some other local residents aren’t so paranoid about litter as me - some walk past bits of paper/bags etc and leave it (even though it might be on their property). I’m not saying they dropped it (it probably came out of a passing car) - but some people seem to have more sensitive ‘rubbish radar’ than others…..

People who leave litter on my fishery get banned for life. I expect people to tell me if they leave line in a tree/crack off a long length of line etc etc. But many just keep quiet.
 
I’m not on a soap box.Just making an observation.I still think you’re being very judgemental ...

So I'm being judgemental, whereas you're just making an observation. 😂

When I say that if people get something for next to nothing they don't always appreciate the value of it, it's not judgemental, it's an observation about human nature.
.
 
No, I'm not saying that at all, so you can get off your soap box.

I'm saying that, for a lot of people, if they get something for next to nothing they place a low value on it and don't respect or cherish it.

It's funny how, regardless of income, everyone seems able and willing to buy a smart phone, without grumbling about the obscene profits Samsung and Apple are making. Yet when it comes to paying more than £45.00 for an annual fishing permit they cry discrimination against those on low incomes.

Society has its priorities wrong.
.
.
This is it, a come one and all policy for the cost of fish and chip supper is never going to attract those who care about such things.
 
I came across a family a while back on a BAA stretch of the Severn. Actually they were difficult to avoid with music? Pounding out at a deafening volume. They seemed friendly enough though not surprisingly I left them to it and went somewhere else!
Next day I returned and I couldn't believe the scene. Rubbish everywhere, excrement and paper among the rocks and batteries in the water in the margins! I was absolutely speechless. I don't think it is possible to get inside the head of people who do that to such a lovely place. Certainly I wouldn't want to anyway. 😐
 
I used to be member of a club in Cheshire (Elworth AA) that had a policy that anglers were responsible for any litter in their swim e.g. anything that other anglers had left behind. This meant that before you started fishing you had to have a scout around the swim and pick up any litter present as the penalty for being found fishing in a littered swim was instant expulsion from the club. The same club also banned any tins from its waters, so if you wanted to use tinned baits like sweetcorn or meat, you had to decant them into bait tubs before you left home. That all might sound draconian - but it worked, I don't recall ever having to pick anyone else's litter.
 
I'm saying that, for a lot of people, if they get something for next to nothing they place a low value on it and don't respect or cherish it.

It's funny how, regardless of income, everyone seems able and willing to buy a smart phone, without grumbling about the obscene profits Samsung and Apple are making. Yet when it comes to paying more than £45.00 for an annual fishing permit they cry discrimination against those on low incomes.

Society has its priorities wrong.
I agree with that.

Same with anglers who will happily spend hundreds on new tackle each season and a fair whack on baitevery session, but begrudge contributing a relative pittance to an organisation willing to take polluters to court.
 
Back
Top