• You need to be a registered member of Barbel Fishing World to post on these forums. Some of the forums are hidden from non-members. Please refer to the instructions on the ‘Register’ page for details of how to join the new incarnation of BFW...

Flourocarbon

I use a Seaguar Soft Plus leader/hooklength for rolling meat because of its limpness. But the limper the line, the softer it is. That is, if you need a highly abrasion resistant line, you need the springy stuff (and higher diameter). It's a trade-off, but I find Soft Plus to be by far the best compromise.
 
I bought some Seaguar Grand Max. Has many followers. It is quite supple and very fine! For certain situations it is certainly ideal but personally I prefer a thicker, tougher make for Barbel amongst rocks and snags. My favourite is Fox Illusion in 12lb which is plenty fine enough for Barbel I think. Having used it successfully for maggot fishing with size 12 hooks I am confident in it.
The Korda IQ 2 is another good one and I have used it extensively for Carp and it is extremely reliable tied with the usual palomar knot. 🙂
 
I use 19lb Soft Plus when I want the best.

Any old cheap stuff off Amazon when I don’t care. I buy it by diameter and it works okay for dirty water fishing.

Last week I was fly fishing in Mexico and my guide asked me for some 16 lb Fluoro for a new tippet. For fun I produced a spool of 15lb IQ2. The guide laughed and chucked it back at me - he said it was too thick. I then produced some 19lb Soft Plus and he happily tied that on. It is much thinner than 15lb IQ2.
 
I use 19lb Soft Plus when I want the best.

Any old cheap stuff off Amazon when I don’t care. I buy it by diameter and it works okay for dirty water fishing.

Last week I was fly fishing in Mexico and my guide asked me for some 16 lb Fluoro for a new tippet. For fun I produced a spool of 15lb IQ2. The guide laughed and chucked it back at me - he said it was too thick. I then produced some 19lb Soft Plus and he happily tied that on. It is much thinner than 15lb IQ2.
Correct about IQ2. It isn't thin. But then that isn't always a desirable quality is it? Also stiffness is what I look for in anti eject rigs. I stand by what I said. IQ2 is excellent for certain situations as is Illusion. I think the reason stiffness can be desirable is because it is not easy to blow out once taken in.
I dont have this obsession with suppleness though certainly for some presentations and certain species it is desirable. If you watch Carp or Barbel feeding they suck in all sorts of stuff. Bits of stick, gravel, chod..... What I do tend to do with stiffer hooklinks is use a semi buoyant hookbait. It really flies into the mouth when sucked in. I might also use a supple hair if using something like casters or other small light baits. Another thing about supple hooklinks: small fish can tie them in knots plus they tangle on the cast! They are not for me you've probably guessed that! 😅
 
Correct about IQ2. It isn't thin. But then that isn't always a desirable quality is it? Also stiffness is what I look for in anti eject rigs. I stand by what I said. IQ2 is excellent for certain situations as is Illusion. I think the reason stiffness can be desirable is because it is not easy to blow out once taken in.
I dont have this obsession with suppleness though certainly for some presentations and certain species it is desirable. If you watch Carp or Barbel feeding they suck in all sorts of stuff. Bits of stick, gravel, chod..... What I do tend to do with stiffer hooklinks is use a semi buoyant hookbait. It really flies into the mouth when sucked in. I might also use a supple hair if using something like casters or other small light baits. Another thing about supple hooklinks: small fish can tie them in knots plus they tangle on the cast! They are not for me you've probably guessed that! 😅
I still use heavy mono for certain rigs (it’s cheap) and add thick braid for the hook end on occasions too.

I even caught 2 decent permit on mono last week - which according to the marketing gurus is impossible !

And I do like a small wafter or half a pop up……
 
I still use heavy mono for certain rigs (it’s cheap) and add thick braid for the hook end on occasions too.

I even caught 2 decent permit on mono last week - which according to the marketing gurus is impossible !

And I do like a small wafter or half a pop up……
Me too Tim. 👍
 
Does anyone actually test the BS of flurocarbon hooklength material? The reason I ask it that from my own tests, it typically fails well below its stated BS. In open water fishing its not that big a deal, but in challenging swim situations, you need something 100% reliable.

The one which has really grabbed my attention in a positive way, is ESP Soft Ghost in 15lb. In my own testing, it lifted a 14lb cast iron weight off the ground multiple times and didn’t fail at the figure of eight loop or combi knot (back to back grinner).

I’ve also recently bought some 16lb Tiger Line. Its failing below its stated BS with said cast iron weight test. I’m yet to determine at what weight it consistently snaps…… a job for later this week hopefully.

By comparison, most mono lines I’ve used, fail around or above their stated BS e.g. Big Game, Bass Pro EXCEL, Gardner Speci Tuff, Drennan Camo XT…..
 
Does anyone actually test the BS of flurocarbon hooklength material? The reason I ask it that from my own tests, it typically fails well below its stated BS. In open water fishing its not that big a deal, but in challenging swim situations, you need something 100% reliable.

The one which has really grabbed my attention in a positive way, is ESP Soft Ghost in 15lb. In my own testing, it lifted a 14lb cast iron weight off the ground multiple times and didn’t fail at the figure of eight loop or combi knot (back to back grinner).

I’ve also recently bought some 16lb Tiger Line. Its failing below its stated BS with said cast iron weight test. I’m yet to determine at what weight it consistently snaps…… a job for later this week hopefully.

By comparison, most mono lines I’ve used, fail around or above their stated BS e.g. Big Game, Bass Pro EXCEL, Gardner Speci Tuff, Drennan Camo XT…..
If it’s any help I used 16lb Tiger line as mainline when it was first released with no issues. I had carp to 40 + on that set up.

There is very interesting post currently on ‘carp forum’ about Fluoro breaking strain. The gist is; it doesn’t work in short lengths but is fine in longer sections. That squares with my and others issues’ with short Fluoro hooklinks on heli rigs - they snap…..So the smart money is now on short braided links for that job.

There is also the diameter issue - Soft Ghost might be thicker than similar nominal breaking strain Tiger line. And I expect that 19lb Soft Plus may well be ‘less strong’ that the 15lb IQ2 I talked about earlier. But the Soft Plus is markedly thinner…..and I’ve never snapped it (on a fish) in either fresh or saltwater.
 
If it’s any help I used 16lb Tiger line as mainline when it was first released with no issues. I had carp to 40 + on that set up.

There is very interesting post currently on ‘carp forum’ about Fluoro breaking strain. The gist is; it doesn’t work in short lengths but is fine in longer sections. That squares with my and others issues’ with short Fluoro hooklinks on heli rigs - they snap…..So the smart money is now on short braided links for that job.

There is also the diameter issue - Soft Ghost might be thicker than similar nominal breaking strain Tiger line. And I expect that 19lb Soft Plus may well be ‘less strong’ that the 15lb IQ2 I talked about earlier. But the Soft Plus is markedly thinner…..and I’ve never snapped it (on a fish) in either fresh or saltwater.
Thanks for the Tiger Line confirmation re confidence.

And re stronger hooklength BS, the guy who just won the Drennan cup has a Barbel video on fishflix. In conjunction with the 16lb Tiger Line he was using a short 20lb Flurocarbon hooklink
 
Blood knot rulrs with flouro
I keep reading this but it gives me the shivers!

Typically I use a 7lb Flurocarbon hooklength in my winter Chub fishing. I’ve had 7 turn blood knots slip and fail on several occasions. As a result I now use a knotless knot or more commonly a polymer knot.
 
Back
Top